
Bankers challenge CFPB’s Safe Account rule, setting up fight over meaning of “customer service”
Judicial | Q1, 2026
WASHINGTON, D.C. – The American Bankers Association today asked the District of Columbia Circuit court to strike down portions of a new Consumer Financial Protection Bureau rule governing low cost bank accounts, arguing that the agency turned a narrow congressional prohibition on inferior customer service into a much broader requirement that banks provide nearly identical service across their banking operations.
The challenge, American Bankers Association v. Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, targets regulations implementing the Safe Account Act, part of the American Economic Opportunity Act of 2024.
Congress required federally insured banks and credit unions with more than $10 billion in assets to offer at least one low-cost transaction account. Those accounts may charge no more than $5 per month, cannot impose overdraft or insufficient-funds fees, and must provide debit cards, direct deposit, online and mobile banking, and ordinary payment and withdrawal services.
But the lawsuit focuses on a different provision of the law: Congress’s command that banks may not provide Safe Account customers with “materially inferior customer service.”
The CFPB interpreted that language broadly.
Under the bureau’s final rule, banks generally cannot give Safe Account customers substantially worse access to branches or ATMs, shorter customer service hours, slower telephone support tiers, or reduced access to ordinary digital features available to customers with standard checking accounts.
The ABA’s argument is simple: Congress spelled out what Safe Accounts must include. The law specifically requires debit cards, withdrawals, transfers, bill payment, and online and mobile banking. The ABA says the separate ban on “materially inferior customer service” was meant to stop banks from treating Safe Account customers worse when they need help, not to require the same branch access, ATM access, service hours, or digital features as other accounts.
The CFPB takes the broader view.
The bureau argues that Congress wanted Safe Accounts to be usable in practice, not just compliant on paper. A bank could otherwise offer all of the required features while making the account much harder to use, for example, by limiting customers to fewer branches or ATMs or giving them worse customer support.
That leaves the D.C. Circuit with a relatively straightforward question: how much did Congress mean by “materially inferior customer service”?
In practical terms, the case will determine whether a bank can offer a Safe Account with all of Congress’s required features while still limiting where and how customers can use them.
If the ABA is right, the CFPB may regulate the specific services Congress listed but has less power to require broader parity between Safe Accounts and ordinary checking accounts.
If the CFPB is right, regulators can also step in when banks technically provide the required services but make Safe Accounts meaningfully worse to use.
The ABA is asking the court to strike down those broader parts of the rule while leaving the Safe Account program itself in place.