Currently: Q1, 2017 (Ends Sunday, November 21st at 11:59 PM EST (7 days)
Join our Discord server! See Discord icon under this banner!

DEBATE: American Infrastructure Renewal Act of 2017

Presiding Officer

Administrator
Staff member
Admin
The Senate will come to order.

Pursuant to the direction of the Senate Majority Leader, debate is now open on American Infrastructure Renewal Act of 2017.

Automatic Senate cloture
The IVS cloture vote is scheduled for 2026-11-22 23:34 UTC, one week after opening. If leadership records an IVS failure, the negotiated NPC vote is scheduled for 2026-11-29 23:34 UTC, two weeks after opening. A round can open once any pending vote or motion is resolved.

Members may debate the measure and offer motions or amendments in accordance with the Senate Rules.

Original legislation

--------------------

Mr. Pritchard (for himself; with thanks to Mr. DeFazio)​

To provide long-term investment in the Nation's roads, bridges, water systems, railways, broadband networks, ports, airports, and other critical infrastructure, to support American jobs and economic development, and for other purposes.

Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,

This Act may be cited as the “American Infrastructure Renewal Act of 2017.”

The purposes of this Act are—

  1. to repair and modernize aging infrastructure throughout the United States;
  2. to improve the safety and reliability of roads, bridges, water systems, railways, ports, and airports;
  3. to expand access to high-speed broadband in rural and underserved communities;
  4. to strengthen domestic manufacturing and create American jobs;
  5. to assist State and local governments with infrastructure projects that exceed local financial capacity; and
  6. to improve the long-term efficiency and reliability of the Nation's transportation and utility systems.

The Secretary of Transportation shall provide additional funding to States for—

  1. repair and reconstruction of highways and major roads;
  2. resurfacing and maintenance of deteriorating roadways;
  3. replacement of unsafe or obsolete bridges;
  4. improvement of major freight corridors; and
  5. projects designed to reduce congestion and improve transportation safety.
The Secretary shall establish a competitive grant program for the repair or replacement of bridges determined to be—

  1. structurally deficient;
  2. functionally obsolete;
  3. essential to interstate or regional commerce; or
  4. financially difficult for State or local governments to replace without Federal assistance.
Priority shall be given to projects involving significant safety concerns.

Not less than 20 percent of funds made available under this title shall be reserved for infrastructure projects serving rural communities and small towns.


The Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency shall provide grants and low-interest loans for—

  1. replacement of aging drinking-water infrastructure;
  2. removal and replacement of lead service lines;
  3. modernization of water-treatment facilities;
  4. repair of leaking water systems; and
  5. improvements necessary to ensure compliance with Federal drinking-water standards.
Federal assistance may be provided for—

  1. wastewater-treatment facilities;
  2. sewer-system repairs;
  3. storm-water management;
  4. replacement of failing septic systems in qualifying communities; and
  5. projects intended to prevent contamination of rivers, lakes, and groundwater.

The Secretary of Transportation shall provide funding for—

  1. repair and modernization of existing passenger-rail infrastructure;
  2. improvement of Amtrak routes and stations;
  3. replacement of aging rail equipment; and
  4. development of additional intercity passenger-rail service where economically justified.
Grants may be awarded for projects that—

  1. eliminate freight bottlenecks;
  2. improve rail crossings;
  3. strengthen connections between railroads, ports, and manufacturing centers; and
  4. improve the safety of freight transportation.
Federal transit assistance may be used for—

  1. repair or replacement of buses and rail vehicles;
  2. modernization of transit stations;
  3. maintenance of existing transit systems; and
  4. expansion of service in growing metropolitan areas.

The Secretary of Commerce, in coordination with the Federal Communications Commission and the Department of Agriculture, shall establish grants and loans to expand broadband access in communities lacking reliable high-speed internet service.

Priority shall be given to—

  1. rural communities;
  2. economically distressed areas;
  3. schools and libraries;
  4. healthcare facilities; and
  5. communities where private providers have determined that broadband deployment is not economically feasible without assistance.
Recipients of Federal broadband funds shall—

  1. provide service at reasonable rates;
  2. meet minimum speed and reliability standards;
  3. report project expenditures; and
  4. return funds obtained through fraud or material misrepresentation.

The Secretary of Transportation may provide grants for—

  1. modernization of commercial ports;
  2. repair of docks and shipping facilities;
  3. improvement of freight connections;
  4. dredging and navigation improvements; and
  5. security and safety upgrades.
Funds may be used for the repair and modernization of—

  1. locks;
  2. dams;
  3. navigation channels; and
  4. other infrastructure necessary for commercial transportation on inland waterways.
The Federal Aviation Administration shall provide additional assistance for—

  1. runway repair;
  2. terminal modernization;
  3. air-traffic safety improvements; and
  4. infrastructure at small and regional airports.

The Secretary of Energy may provide grants and loans for projects that—

  1. improve the reliability of the electrical grid;
  2. replace aging transmission infrastructure;
  3. strengthen electrical systems against severe weather and other disruptions;
  4. improve connections between regional electrical systems; and
  5. reduce unnecessary power losses.
Infrastructure projects receiving funds under this Act may incorporate reasonable improvements intended to reduce damage caused by—

  1. floods;
  2. tornadoes;
  3. hurricanes;
  4. severe storms;
  5. drought; and
  6. other natural disasters.

The Secretary of Transportation shall establish a competitive grant program for counties, municipalities, and regional authorities undertaking major infrastructure projects.

Special consideration shall be given to communities that—

  1. demonstrate significant infrastructure deterioration;
  2. lack sufficient local revenue to complete necessary repairs;
  3. provide a reasonable local or State contribution; or
  4. demonstrate that the project will provide substantial economic or public-safety benefits.
Federal agencies administering programs under this Act shall provide technical assistance to smaller communities that lack the personnel or financial resources necessary to prepare complex Federal grant applications.


To the greatest extent permitted by existing trade obligations, iron, steel, manufactured products, and construction materials used in projects funded under this Act shall be produced in the United States.

Waivers may be granted when—

  1. necessary materials are not reasonably available domestically;
  2. domestic materials would result in an unreasonable increase in project costs; or
  3. application of the requirement would be inconsistent with the public interest.
Recipients of funds under this Act shall comply with applicable Federal wage, workplace-safety, and labor laws.


Each Federal agency distributing funds under this Act shall—

  1. publicly report major grants and contracts;
  2. establish procedures to prevent waste, fraud, and abuse;
  3. conduct periodic audits of funded projects; and
  4. recover funds used for unauthorized purposes.
In awarding discretionary grants, Federal agencies shall give priority to the repair, replacement, or modernization of existing infrastructure before funding projects whose primary purpose is the construction of entirely new facilities.

Federal agencies may withdraw funding from projects that fail to demonstrate substantial progress within a reasonable period.

Unused funds shall be returned to the Treasury or reassigned to another eligible infrastructure project.


There are authorized to be appropriated $250,000,000,000 over five fiscal years, 2018 through 2022, to carry out this Act.

Funds shall be distributed approximately as follows—

  1. $110 billion for roads and bridges;
  2. $35 billion for drinking-water and wastewater systems;
  3. $30 billion for passenger rail, freight rail, and public transportation;
  4. $20 billion for rural broadband and telecommunications;
  5. $20 billion for ports, waterways, and airports;
  6. $20 billion for electrical-grid and utility infrastructure; and
  7. $15 billion for competitive State and local infrastructure grants.
Not later than 180 days after enactment, the Director of the Office of Management and Budget shall submit to Congress recommendations for financing the expenditures authorized under this Act through a combination of—

  1. existing infrastructure revenues;
  2. elimination of duplicative Federal programs;
  3. recovery of unpaid Federal fees and taxes;
  4. public-private infrastructure financing where appropriate; and
  5. other savings or revenues enacted by Congress.
Nothing in this section shall authorize the Executive Branch to impose a new tax without an Act of Congress.


Nothing in this Act shall be construed to require a State or local government to participate in a program established under this Act.

Nothing in this Act shall expand existing Federal eminent-domain authority.

This Act shall take effect on October 1, 2017.

PES

This bill would invest $250 billion over five years to repair and modernize American infrastructure, with a focus on maintaining existing roads, bridges, water systems, railways, broadband networks, ports, airports, and the electric grid.

The bill would provide $110 billion for roads and bridges, $35 billion for water and wastewater systems, $30 billion for rail and public transit, $20 billion for rural broadband, $20 billion for ports, waterways, and airports, $20 billion for electric-grid improvements, and $15 billion for competitive state and local infrastructure grants.

At least 20 percent of road and bridge funding would be reserved for rural communities and small towns. The bill would also prioritize repairing existing infrastructure before funding entirely new projects.

Projects receiving federal funding would generally be required to use American-made iron, steel, manufactured products, and construction materials, while complying with federal labor and workplace-safety laws.

The bill would create stronger oversight requirements to prevent waste, fraud, and abuse, including public reporting, audits, project deadlines, and recovery of improperly spent funds.

The bill would also expand federal assistance to smaller communities that may lack the resources to compete for major infrastructure grants and would invest in broadband expansion for rural and underserved areas.

Overall, the bill is intended to repair aging infrastructure, create American jobs, improve transportation and utilities, strengthen rural communities, and provide state and local governments with additional resources for major infrastructure projects while maintaining fiscal oversight.
 
Mr. President,

I rise today in support of the American Infrastructure Renewal Act of 2017.

And I want to start with something that ought to be obvious.

A pothole does not know whether you are a Democrat or a Republican.

A collapsing bridge does not check your voter registration.

A water main does not care who you voted for in November.

For years, Americans from both parties have been telling Washington the same damn thing: fix what we already have.

That is what this bill is about.

The American Infrastructure Renewal Act invests $250 billion over five years in the physical foundation of this country.

That means repairing roads and bridges.

Modernizing drinking-water systems.

Improving rail and public transportation.

Expanding broadband into communities that have been left behind.

Strengthening our ports, airports, waterways, electrical grid, and other essential infrastructure.

And we are putting repair first.

Before Washington starts dreaming up shiny new projects, we ought to make sure the bridge people drive across every morning is not falling apart.

This legislation also says something else that I think most Americans agree with:

If American taxpayers are paying for it, we ought to be putting American workers to work.

That is why this bill includes strong Buy American provisions and labor protections.

If we are going to spend billions rebuilding America, then American steelworkers ought to be making the steel. American construction workers ought to be pouring the concrete. American manufacturers ought to be building the equipment.

And those jobs ought to pay enough that the person doing the work can raise a family on them.

This is not just a big-city bill.

I come from Indiana. I know what happens when a rural county has one bridge carrying farmers, school buses, ambulances, and workers into town and that bridge starts falling apart.

I know what it means when a small business cannot get reliable broadband.

I know what it means when a town has water lines older than half the people living there.

So this bill makes certain that rural America gets its fair share.

Now, there are going to be arguments about the price tag.

There should be.

Two hundred and fifty billion dollars is a lot of money, and anybody asking taxpayers for that much ought to be prepared to explain where every dollar is going.

That is why this legislation includes oversight, auditing, competitive funding, and accountability requirements.

I am a Democrat, but I have never believed that spending money automatically means solving a problem.

Spend it wisely.

Measure the results.

And if somebody is wasting taxpayer money, stop sending them checks.

That ought to be common sense.

And common sense is really what brings us here.

Go home and ask a Democrat whether the bridge ought to be safe.

Ask a Republican whether their town ought to have clean drinking water.

Ask somebody who has never voted for either one of us whether their kid ought to have access to high-speed internet.

You are going to get pretty similar answers.

Infrastructure has broad support because Americans actually use this stuff every day.

They may disagree about taxes.

They may disagree about healthcare.

They may disagree about guns, immigration, abortion, or a hundred other issues we argue about in this chamber.

But they all drive on the same roads.

They all depend on the same electrical grid.

Their businesses ship products through the same ports.

Their families drink water from the same pipes.

This is exactly the kind of issue where this Senate ought to prove that divided government does not have to mean dysfunctional government.

We have a Democratic President.

We have a Democratic Senate.

We have a Republican House.

Nobody is getting everything they want.

Good.

That means everybody ought to have a reason to sit down and negotiate.

I am not asking my Republican colleagues to become Democrats.

Hell, I do not always agree with every Democrat in this building either.

I am asking them to look at the roads and bridges in their own states and tell me they do not need work.

I am asking them to look at the rural communities waiting for broadband.

The towns dealing with aging water systems.

The ports that need modernization.

The workers who are ready to put on a hard hat and get to work.

Then come sit down with us.

If you think part of this bill costs too much, tell me where.

If you think we can build something better, bring the amendment.

If you have a project in your state that has been ignored for twenty years, make the case.

That is how the Senate is supposed to work.

This bill does not belong to Russell Pritchard.

It does not belong to the Democratic Party.

And if we do this right, by the time it reaches the President's desk, Republicans will have fingerprints on it too.

It belongs to the American people who have been paying taxes for years while watching the infrastructure around them get older.

They have waited long enough.

Let us put Americans back to work.

Let us rebuild what previous generations built for us.

And let us leave the next generation something worth inheriting.

I urge my colleagues on both sides of the aisle to support the American Infrastructure Renewal Act of 2017.

Let’s get to work.
 
Mr. President—

I rise.

No child in America should brush their teeth with lead, and no motorist should cross a bridge wondering whether gravity is about to win the argument. On that much, even this chamber can manage consensus.

However, I have two serious objections to this bill, and I will be offering amendments to cure both before it ever earns my vote.

First: how, precisely, are we paying for it? As drafted, this legislation authorizes two hundred and fifty billion dollars today, and then politely informs us that the White House will send over a few ideas on how to cover the tab six months from now.

Really. Six months from now.

Have we entirely forgotten that we are stewards of the public treasury? I certainly have not. Nor have my Republican colleagues. Yet this administration treats a quarter of a trillion dollars the way a teenager treats someone else’s American Express card—swipe first, invent an explanation later. Treating facts, arithmetic, and explicit campaign promises as optional suggestions has become an exhausting habit with this White House, and one I intend to break.

In the real world, civilized adults establish how they are paying for something before they order it. When I served as president of Bowdoin College, we did not break ground on a new dormitory and hope a benefactor might wander across the quad six months later with a checkbook. You secure the endowment, you verify the ledger, and then you pour the concrete.

One would assume the President learned that same elementary lesson managing a community hospital in Cottonwood County, Minnesota—alongside all the other homespun wisdom from that anthropomorphic Hallmark card she was apparently raised in.

My first amendment puts an end to this fiscal theater. Instead of handing the executive branch a two-hundred-and-fifty-billion-dollar gift card today and waiting half a year for a postscript from the budget office, my amendment locks the vault: funds unlock strictly in tranches, dollar for dollar, only after Congress enacts real offsets that add not one penny to the deficit. And to jump-start our first wave of rural projects immediately, we sweep billions out of Washington’s neglected couch cushions—dusty, unspent stimulus accounts, idle loan subsidies, and duplicative grants.

Article I vests the power of the purse in Congress, Mr. President, not the West Wing. It is high time we started acting like it.

Plain English Summary (PES)

Replaces the bill’s delayed financing study with a strict “Pay-As-You-Go” rule so this infrastructure bill cannot add a dime to the national debt. While states and towns can start applying for grants, designing projects, and clearing environmental reviews right away, no construction money can actually be spent unless and until Congress passes real spending cuts or user fees to pay for it dollar-for-dollar. To get the first wave of projects funded immediately without borrowing new money, this amendment sweeps unspent, leftover cash from old 2009 stimulus accounts, unused energy loan programs, and duplicate grant funds—and guarantees that at least 20 percent of every dollar unlocked goes directly to rural communities and small towns.

AMENDMENT NO. ___(Purpose: To prohibit the obligation of funds unless offset dollar-for-dollar by enacted deficit-reduction measures, and to rescind unobligated federal balances to finance initial infrastructure investments.)

Strike the financing section of the bill (relating to Office of Management and Budget recommendations not later than 180 days after enactment) and insert the following:

SEC. ___. FISCAL INTEGRITY, PAY-AS-YOU-GO OFFSET TRIGGER, AND RESCISSION OF UNSPENT BALANCES.

(a) Short Title.— This section may be cited as the “Pay-As-You-Go Infrastructure Accountability Act of 2017”.

(b) Pay-As-You-Go Obligation Lock.— (1) Prohibition on Unfunded Obligations.— Notwithstanding any other provision of this Act, no Federal agency may obligate or expend any funds authorized under this Act for construction, acquisition, or capital grants unless and until the Director of the Congressional Budget Office certifies in writing to Congress that legislation enacted on or after the date of enactment of this Act (including subsection (d) of this section) achieves net direct spending reductions, permanent rescissions of unobligated budget authority, or dedicated user-fee receipts equal to or greater than the amount to be obligated over the same fiscal year period. (2) Tranched Release of Funds.— As the Congressional Budget Office certifies enacted offsets under paragraph (1), funds shall be released for obligation in tranches equal to the certified offset amount and allocated proportionally across the funding categories established under this Act, except that not less than 20 percent of each released tranche shall be reserved exclusively for rural communities and small towns. (3) Pre-Construction Readiness Permitted.— Nothing in paragraph (1) shall prohibit Federal agencies, States, or local governments from accepting grant applications, ranking eligible projects, conducting engineering designs, or completing expedited environmental reviews prior to the release of construction funds.

(c) Prohibition on Tax Increases.— Nothing in this section shall be construed to authorize the Executive Branch to impose any new tax, tariff, or fee, or to increase any existing tax rate, without an Act of Congress.

(d) Immediate Rescission of Unobligated Balances and Duplicative Accounts.— (1) Permanent Rescissions.— Effective upon the date of enactment of this Act, there are permanently rescinded and transferred to the general fund of the Treasury to serve as initial certified offsets under subsection (b)— (A) all unobligated balances remaining available from appropriations enacted under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (Public Law 111–5) as of September 30, 2017; (B) 50 percent of the unobligated credit-subsidy balances remaining available for the Innovative Technology Loan Guarantee Program under title XVII of the Energy Policy Act of 2005 (42 U.S.C. 16511 et seq.) that have remained unobligated for more than 36 months; and (C) all unobligated balances exceeding $10,000,000 in discretionary grant accounts administered by the Economic Development Administration that duplicate infrastructure grant authorities established under this Act. (2) OMB Accounting Report.— Not later than 30 days after the date of enactment of this Act, the Director of the Office of Management and Budget shall submit to the Committees on the Budget and Appropriations of the Senate and the House of Representatives a complete account-by-account ledger of the amounts rescinded under paragraph (1) and any remaining unspent discretionary balances available for subsequent offset legislation.

(e) Deficit Neutrality Enforcement.— Any authorization of appropriations under this Act that remains unmatched by certified offsets under subsection (b) as of September 30, 2022, shall automatically expire and be canceled without further action by Congress.

Investing in infrastructure is indeed necessary. Yet anyone who has ever bothered to speak with a contractor who won a public bid to replace a simple culvert knows the bureaucratic purgatory that is America’s permitting process.

If we want this two hundred and fifty billion dollars to produce actual concrete, steel, and economic multiplier effects—rather than endless billable hours—we must streamline NEPA. Until we reform permitting, the primary beneficiaries of this legislation will not be children drinking from lead pipes or commuters crossing aging bridges, but environmental law firms specializing in National Pollutant Discharge Elimination System litigation.

My second amendment puts an end to the alphabet-soup obstacle course where a dozen federal agencies and layers of well-intentioned middle management each demand their own separate sign-off. Under my amendment, one lead agency conducts one joint environmental review. Is it a highway or bridge project? The Department of Transportation takes the wheel. Is it a wastewater treatment plant? The EPA leads. Every other agency—from the Army Corps of Engineers to the Fish and Wildlife Service—coordinates inside that single process.

Environmental Impact Statements will carry a hard statutory cap: two years and one hundred and fifty pages. Routine Environmental Assessments? One year and seventy-five pages. Every project will still undergo rigorous environmental scrutiny—it will simply be managed with competence, discipline, and basic respect for the taxpayer’s clock. If we are serious about rebuilding American infrastructure, then let us build it. Let us new water mains and modern sewer systems -- not finance a new cedar deck for a senior partner with a law degree and a LexisNexis subscription.
Plain English Summary (PES)

Streamlines federal environmental reviews and permitting under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) so federally funded infrastructure projects can be built faster without getting stuck in years of red tape and lawsuits. Specifically, this amendment:

  • Puts One Agency in Charge: Requires a single lead agency and one joint environmental review ("One Federal Decision") instead of separate, overlapping reviews across multiple federal agencies.
  • Sets Hard Deadlines and Page Limits: Caps major Environmental Impact Statements at 2 years and 150 pages, and smaller Environmental Assessments at 1 year and 75 pages.
  • Fast-Tracks Routine Repairs: Automatically exempts basic repairs, replacements, and broadband upgrades inside existing road, rail, or utility corridors from lengthy environmental studies.
  • Keeps Reviews Practical: Limits studies to direct, reasonably foreseeable local environmental impacts rather than distant or speculative scenarios.
  • Prevents Endless Lawsuits: Gives challengers 150 days to file suit (only if they submitted formal public comments earlier) and prevents courts from halting construction over minor paperwork errors unless a project poses an imminent threat to human health or safety.
AMENDMENT NO. ___(Purpose: To streamline Federal environmental reviews, establish binding permitting timelines, expand categorical exclusions, and limit dilatory judicial challenges for infrastructure projects.)

At the appropriate place in the bill, insert the following:

SEC. ___. STREAMLINING ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEWS AND PERMITTING FOR INFRASTRUCTURE.

(a) Short Title.— This section may be cited as the “Building Faster and Smarter Permitting Reform Act of 2017”.

(b) Amendments to the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969.— Title I of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4331 et seq.) is amended by adding at the end the following:

“SEC. 106. TIMELY AND STREAMLINED INFRASTRUCTURE REVIEWS.

“(a) One Federal Decision.—“(1) Lead Agency and Single Document.— For any covered infrastructure project requiring authorization or review by multiple Federal agencies, the Secretary of Transportation (or the primary funding agency) shall designate a single Federal lead agency to supervise the preparation of one single environmental document relied upon by all cooperating Federal agencies for all required permits, licenses, and approvals.“(2) Concurrent Authorization Schedule.— All cooperating agencies shall conduct reviews concurrently and issue final permit decisions not later than 90 days after issuance of the Record of Decision.

“(b) Statutory Deadlines and Page Limits.—“(1) Deadlines.— Unless a shorter period applies, a Federal agency shall complete—“(A) an Environmental Impact Statement not later than 2 years after the date of publication of a notice of intent; and“(B) an Environmental Assessment not later than 1 year after the date the agency determines an assessment is required.“(2) Deemed Approval Remedy.— If a Federal agency fails to meet a deadline under paragraph (1) or subsection (a)(2), the project sponsor may petition a United States district court for an expedited order compelling agency action within 60 days, or the permit shall be deemed compliant for purposes of obligating Federal funds.“(3) Page Limits.— Excluding appendices and citations, an Environmental Impact Statement shall not exceed 150 pages (or 300 pages for projects of extraordinary complexity), and an Environmental Assessment shall not exceed 75 pages.

“(c) Categorical Exclusions for Repairs and Existing Corridors.—“(1) Automatic Exclusion.— No Environmental Impact Statement or Environmental Assessment shall be required under section 102(2)(C) for any project funded under the American Infrastructure Renewal Act of 2017 that—“(A) repairs, reconstructs, resurfaces, or replaces an existing highway, bridge, rail line, water main, port facility, runway, or electric transmission line within an existing operational right-of-way or previously disturbed footprint;“(B) deploys broadband infrastructure within an existing utility, road, or rail corridor; or“(C) receives less than $10,000,000 in Federal financial assistance or represents less than 15 percent of total project costs.“(2) Shared Exclusions.— Any Federal agency may adopt and apply a categorical exclusion established by any other Federal agency without conducting a separate rulemaking.

“(d) Scope of Review.—“(1) Reasonably Foreseeable Effects Only.— Environmental documents shall evaluate only reasonably foreseeable direct environmental effects of the proposed agency action and technically and economically feasible alternatives that meet the project’s stated purpose and need. Agencies shall not be required to evaluate speculative, remote, or upstream/downstream greenhouse gas scenarios or conduct new baseline scientific research.“(2) State and Tribal Equivalency.— Where a State or Tribal environmental review satisfies substantially equivalent substantive standards, the lead agency shall adopt such review in full satisfaction of this Act.

“(e) Judicial Review Reform.—“(1) Statute of Limitations.— Notwithstanding any other provision of law, any claim seeking judicial review of an authorization or environmental review for a covered project shall be barred unless filed within 150 days after publication of final agency action in the Federal Register.“(2) Standing.— Only a person or entity that submitted timely, substantive written comments during the public comment period (which shall not exceed 60 days) may bring a judicial challenge.“(3) Limitation on Remedies.— This Act establishes procedural requirements only. In any judicial action alleging a violation of this Act, a court shall not vacate, stay, or enjoin a permit, authorization, or construction activity unless the plaintiff proves by clear and convincing evidence that continuing the project poses an imminent and substantial danger to human health or safety. Where a procedural defect is found, the exclusive remedy shall be remand without vacatur for correction within 180 days.”

I yield.
 
PES — Plain English Summary
Replaces the bill’s delayed financing study with a strict “Pay-As-You-Go” rule so this infrastructure bill cannot add a dime to the national debt. While states and towns can start applying for grants, designing projects, and clearing environmental reviews right away, no construction money can actually be spent unless and until Congress passes real spending cuts or user fees to pay for it dollar-for-dollar. To get the first wave of projects funded immediately without borrowing new money, this amendment sweeps unspent, leftover cash from old 2009 stimulus accounts, unused energy loan programs, and duplicate grant funds—and guarantees that at least 20 percent of every dollar unlocked goes directly to rural communities and small towns.

Amendment: Kinsey I

All changes below form one amendment. One second and one AYE / NAY / PRESENT vote cover the entire amendment.

Change 1 — Replace this exact passage:
Overall, the bill is intended to repair aging infrastructure, create American jobs, improve transportation and utilities, strengthen rural communities, and provide state and local governments with additional resources for major infrastructure projects while maintaining fiscal oversight.
[/QUOTE]

With:
AMENDMENT NO. ___(Purpose: To prohibit the obligation of funds unless offset dollar-for-dollar by enacted deficit-reduction measures, and to rescind unobligated federal balances to finance initial infrastructure investments.)

Strike the financing section of the bill (relating to Office of Management and Budget recommendations not later than 180 days after enactment) and insert the following:

SEC. ___. FISCAL INTEGRITY, PAY-AS-YOU-GO OFFSET TRIGGER, AND RESCISSION OF UNSPENT BALANCES.

(a) Short Title.— This section may be cited as the “Pay-As-You-Go Infrastructure Accountability Act of 2017”.

(b) Pay-As-You-Go Obligation Lock.— (1) Prohibition on Unfunded Obligations.— Notwithstanding any other provision of this Act, no Federal agency may obligate or expend any funds authorized under this Act for construction, acquisition, or capital grants unless and until the Director of the Congressional Budget Office certifies in writing to Congress that legislation enacted on or after the date of enactment of this Act (including subsection (d) of this section) achieves net direct spending reductions, permanent rescissions of unobligated budget authority, or dedicated user-fee receipts equal to or greater than the amount to be obligated over the same fiscal year period. (2) Tranched Release of Funds.— As the Congressional Budget Office certifies enacted offsets under paragraph (1), funds shall be released for obligation in tranches equal to the certified offset amount and allocated proportionally across the funding categories established under this Act, except that not less than 20 percent of each released tranche shall be reserved exclusively for rural communities and small towns. (3) Pre-Construction Readiness Permitted.— Nothing in paragraph (1) shall prohibit Federal agencies, States, or local governments from accepting grant applications, ranking eligible projects, conducting engineering designs, or completing expedited environmental reviews prior to the release of construction funds.

(c) Prohibition on Tax Increases.— Nothing in this section shall be construed to authorize the Executive Branch to impose any new tax, tariff, or fee, or to increase any existing tax rate, without an Act of Congress.

(d) Immediate Rescission of Unobligated Balances and Duplicative Accounts.— (1) Permanent Rescissions.— Effective upon the date of enactment of this Act, there are permanently rescinded and transferred to the general fund of the Treasury to serve as initial certified offsets under subsection (b)— (A) all unobligated balances remaining available from appropriations enacted under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (Public Law 111–5) as of September 30, 2017; (B) 50 percent of the unobligated credit-subsidy balances remaining available for the Innovative Technology Loan Guarantee Program under title XVII of the Energy Policy Act of 2005 (42 U.S.C. 16511 et seq.) that have remained unobligated for more than 36 months; and (C) all unobligated balances exceeding $10,000,000 in discretionary grant accounts administered by the Economic Development Administration that duplicate infrastructure grant authorities established under this Act. (2) OMB Accounting Report.— Not later than 30 days after the date of enactment of this Act, the Director of the Office of Management and Budget shall submit to the Committees on the Budget and Appropriations of the Senate and the House of Representatives a complete account-by-account ledger of the amounts rescinded under paragraph (1) and any remaining unspent discretionary balances available for subsequent offset legislation.

(e) Deficit Neutrality Enforcement.— Any authorization of appropriations under this Act that remains unmatched by certified offsets under subsection (b) as of September 30, 2022, shall automatically expire and be canceled without further action by Congress.
 
PES — Plain English Summary
Plain English Summary (PES)

Streamlines federal environmental reviews and permitting under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) so federally funded infrastructure projects can be built faster without getting stuck in years of red tape and lawsuits. Specifically, this amendment:

Puts One Agency in Charge: Requires a single lead agency and one joint environmental review ("One Federal Decision") instead of separate, overlapping reviews across multiple federal agencies.
Sets Hard Deadlines and Page Limits: Caps major Environmental Impact Statements at 2 years and 150 pages, and smaller Environmental Assessments at 1 year and 75 pages.
Fast-Tracks Routine Repairs: Automatically exempts basic repairs, replacements, and broadband upgrades inside existing road, rail, or utility corridors from lengthy environmental studies.
Keeps Reviews Practical: Limits studies to direct, reasonably foreseeable local environmental impacts rather than distant or speculative scenarios.
Prevents Endless Lawsuits: Gives challengers 150 days to file suit (only if they submitted formal public comments earlier) and prevents courts from halting construction over minor paperwork errors unless a project poses an imminent threat to human health or safety.

Amendment: Kinsey II

All changes below form one amendment. One second and one AYE / NAY / PRESENT vote cover the entire amendment.

Change 1 — Replace this exact passage:
[/QUOTE]

With:
AMENDMENT NO. ___(Purpose: To streamline Federal environmental reviews, establish binding permitting timelines, expand categorical exclusions, and limit dilatory judicial challenges for infrastructure projects.)

At the appropriate place in the bill, insert the following:

SEC. ___. STREAMLINING ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEWS AND PERMITTING FOR INFRASTRUCTURE.

(a) Short Title.— This section may be cited as the “Building Faster and Smarter Permitting Reform Act of 2017”.

(b) Amendments to the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969.— Title I of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4331 et seq.) is amended by adding at the end the following:

“SEC. 106. TIMELY AND STREAMLINED INFRASTRUCTURE REVIEWS.

“(a) One Federal Decision.—“(1) Lead Agency and Single Document.— For any covered infrastructure project requiring authorization or review by multiple Federal agencies, the Secretary of Transportation (or the primary funding agency) shall designate a single Federal lead agency to supervise the preparation of one single environmental document relied upon by all cooperating Federal agencies for all required permits, licenses, and approvals.“(2) Concurrent Authorization Schedule.— All cooperating agencies shall conduct reviews concurrently and issue final permit decisions not later than 90 days after issuance of the Record of Decision.

“(b) Statutory Deadlines and Page Limits.—“(1) Deadlines.— Unless a shorter period applies, a Federal agency shall complete—“(A) an Environmental Impact Statement not later than 2 years after the date of publication of a notice of intent; and“(B) an Environmental Assessment not later than 1 year after the date the agency determines an assessment is required.“(2) Deemed Approval Remedy.— If a Federal agency fails to meet a deadline under paragraph (1) or subsection (a)(2), the project sponsor may petition a United States district court for an expedited order compelling agency action within 60 days, or the permit shall be deemed compliant for purposes of obligating Federal funds.“(3) Page Limits.— Excluding appendices and citations, an Environmental Impact Statement shall not exceed 150 pages (or 300 pages for projects of extraordinary complexity), and an Environmental Assessment shall not exceed 75 pages.

“(c) Categorical Exclusions for Repairs and Existing Corridors.—“(1) Automatic Exclusion.— No Environmental Impact Statement or Environmental Assessment shall be required under section 102(2)(C) for any project funded under the American Infrastructure Renewal Act of 2017 that—“(A) repairs, reconstructs, resurfaces, or replaces an existing highway, bridge, rail line, water main, port facility, runway, or electric transmission line within an existing operational right-of-way or previously disturbed footprint;“(B) deploys broadband infrastructure within an existing utility, road, or rail corridor; or“(C) receives less than $10,000,000 in Federal financial assistance or represents less than 15 percent of total project costs.“(2) Shared Exclusions.— Any Federal agency may adopt and apply a categorical exclusion established by any other Federal agency without conducting a separate rulemaking.

“(d) Scope of Review.—“(1) Reasonably Foreseeable Effects Only.— Environmental documents shall evaluate only reasonably foreseeable direct environmental effects of the proposed agency action and technically and economically feasible alternatives that meet the project’s stated purpose and need. Agencies shall not be required to evaluate speculative, remote, or upstream/downstream greenhouse gas scenarios or conduct new baseline scientific research.“(2) State and Tribal Equivalency.— Where a State or Tribal environmental review satisfies substantially equivalent substantive standards, the lead agency shall adopt such review in full satisfaction of this Act.

“(e) Judicial Review Reform.—“(1) Statute of Limitations.— Notwithstanding any other provision of law, any claim seeking judicial review of an authorization or environmental review for a covered project shall be barred unless filed within 150 days after publication of final agency action in the Federal Register.“(2) Standing.— Only a person or entity that submitted timely, substantive written comments during the public comment period (which shall not exceed 60 days) may bring a judicial challenge.“(3) Limitation on Remedies.— This Act establishes procedural requirements only. In any judicial action alleging a violation of this Act, a court shall not vacate, stay, or enjoin a permit, authorization, or construction activity unless the plaintiff proves by clear and convincing evidence that continuing the project poses an imminent and substantial danger to human health or safety. Where a procedural defect is found, the exclusive remedy shall be remand without vacatur for correction within 180 days.”
 
Mr. President,

The Kinsey amendments are important but as written will not receive my vote. If the Senator from Maine would like to discuss them, I would ask her to reach out.

I yield.
 
PES — Plain English Summary
This amendment allows economically distressed rural communities to receive reduced or waived local matching requirements, permits qualifying small communities to count donated materials, equipment, or labor toward required matching contributions, and requires agencies to consider local fiscal capacity when evaluating grant applications.

Amendment: Wilberforce I

All changes below form one amendment. One second and one AYE / NAY / PRESENT vote cover the entire amendment.

Change 1 — Insert immediately after this exact passage:
Not less than 20 percent of funds made available under this title shall be reserved for infrastructure projects serving rural communities and small towns.

Text to insert:
RURAL INFRASTRUCTURE COST-SHARING RELIEF.

(a) The head of a Federal agency administering a grant program under this Act may reduce or waive non-Federal matching requirements for a rural county or municipality that demonstrates significant financial hardship, limited local revenue capacity, or an urgent public safety need.

(b) In determining eligibility for such relief, the agency shall consider population, median household income, local tax capacity, and the essential nature of the proposed infrastructure project.

(c) Eligible recipients may satisfy applicable non-Federal matching requirements through documented in-kind contributions, including labor, equipment, and materials.

(d) Nothing in this section shall increase the total amount authorized to be appropriated under this Act.
 
PES — Plain English Summary
This amendment: reserves at least 70% of broadband funding for communities lacking service meeting the FCC benchmark; prohibits federal grants for infrastructure already adequately served (with exceptions for documented capacity or reliability deficiencies); requires grant recipients to demonstrate actual service availability and speeds before receiving final payments; and requires repayment of funds for materially unmet deployment obligations, subject to appropriate exceptions.

Amendment: Wilberforce II

All changes below form one amendment. One second and one AYE / NAY / PRESENT vote cover the entire amendment.

Change 1 — Insert immediately before this exact passage:
The Secretary of Transportation may provide grants for—

Text to insert:
RURAL BROADBAND EXPANSION AND ACCOUNTABILITY.

(a) Not less than 70 percent of funds authorized for broadband expansion under this Act shall be reserved for projects serving communities without reliable fixed broadband access meeting the Federal Communications Commission benchmark of 25 megabits per second download and 3 megabits per second upload.

(b) Federal agencies shall take reasonable steps to prevent duplicative funding in areas already served by infrastructure meeting applicable federal standards.

(c) Grant recipients shall demonstrate that funded networks meet required service availability, speed, and reliability standards before receiving final disbursements.

(d) Federal agencies shall establish procedures to recover funds from recipients who materially fail to fulfill deployment obligations without adequate justification.

(e) Nothing in this section shall increase the total amount authorized to be appropriated under this Act.
 
PES — Plain English Summary
This amendment: requires each federally funded project above $10 million to establish an approved budget, completion timetable, and measurable outcomes; requires annual reporting of expenditures, project delays, cost overruns, and completed improvements; requires an independent review when projected costs exceed the approved budget by more than 20 percent; and allows agencies to suspend additional funding for projects with unjustified overruns (with exceptions).

Amendment: Wilberforce III

All changes below form one amendment. One second and one AYE / NAY / PRESENT vote cover the entire amendment.

Change 1 — Insert immediately after this exact passage:
Unused funds shall be returned to the Treasury or reassigned to another eligible infrastructure project.

Text to insert:
INFRASTRUCTURE PERFORMANCE AND FISCAL ACCOUNTABILITY.

(a) Any infrastructure project receiving more than $10,000,000 in Federal assistance under this Act shall establish an approved budget, a projected completion schedule, and measurable performance objectives.

(b) Federal agencies shall submit annual reports to Congress detailing expenditures, project completion rates, significant delays, cost overruns, and measurable infrastructure improvements.

(c) Any project with projected expenditures exceeding its approved budget by more than 20 percent shall undergo an independent financial and performance review before additional Federal funding is obligated.

(d) Federal agencies may suspend or reallocate funding for projects demonstrating unjustified cost overruns, substantial delays, or failure to meet established objectives. Exceptions may be granted for natural disasters, emergencies, or other documented unforeseen circumstances.

(e) Nothing in this section shall increase the total amount authorized to be appropriated under this Act.
 
Mr. Speaker --

Seantor Pritchard can state publicly on the record. exactly what he believes to be wrong with these amendments. Or he can reach out to me. And then I will say what he believes to be wrong with them on the record.

I yield.
 
Mr. President,

Let me be plain about where I stand. America needs this work done. In my state, the Port of Houston is one of the busiest in the nation, and it moves the goods that keep Texas working. I-35 is choked from Laredo to Dallas. There are farm-to-market roads in West Texas older than most of the people driving on them, and towns in the Hill Country where a child still does homework in a fast-food parking lot because that's where the Wi-Fi is.

This bill gets a great deal right. It says fix it first: repair what we have before we build monuments. It sets aside a fifth of the money for rural America. It claws back money lost to fraud and money sitting in stalled projects. It doesn't expand eminent domain, and it doesn't force any state to take part. Those are conservative principles, and I'm glad to see them written into a bill from across the aisle.

But a good idea badly delivered is a broken promise. I see five places where this bill, as written, would let down the people it's meant to serve aside from the cost element mentioned by my colleague Senator Storm. So today I'm offering five amendments. None of them cuts a dollar. Every one of them is designed to get shovels in the ground faster and money to where the need is.

First, permitting. We can authorize $250 billion tomorrow and not see a single bridge rebuilt for a decade if every project waits years for a stack of reviews from half a dozen agencies. My amendment gives each project one lead agency, one environmental document, one decision and a two-year clock. Repairs on an existing footprint skip the full review. It doesn't weaken a single environmental standard. It just ends the waiting and demands better from our Federal Government.

Second, the formula funding. As drafted, most of this money would be handed out at the discretion of cabinet secretaries, in amounts that are only "approximately" fixed. I don't care which party holds the White House: no administration should be handed a quarter of a trillion dollars to dole out in the run-up to an election. My amendment sends road and water money through the formulas states already know, caps discretionary grants at a quarter of the total, requires published scores, and asks the GAO to audit where every dollar lands.

Third, our grid in my beloved home state. Texas has run its own electric grid for generations, and Texans like it that way. This bill talks about connecting regional systems. My amendment says plainly that nothing in it can force an independent grid, whether in Texas, Alaska or Hawaii, to connect to another or to come under new federal control, and that those grids stay fully eligible for funding despite this reticence.

Fourth, broadband for rural areas and underserviced homes. A family with no internet should come before a town that wants faster internet. My amendment puts the unserved first, lets any technology compete if it meets the standard, stops us paying to duplicate networks companies have already built, and makes clear that "reasonable rates" is not a back door to price controls.

Fifth, labour. The Americans who build this should be paid fairly and work safely. But this bill shouldn't quietly rewrite federal wage law, or let agencies demand union-only agreements as the price of a grant. My amendment keeps existing law exactly as it is, keeps agencies neutral, and rewards projects that train registered apprentices, so a generation of young Americans can learn a trade on these sites.

Mr President, as mentioned this bill doesn't say how the quarter of a trillion dollar spend will be paid for. It is incumbent upon the majority to outline how they intend to pay for it before it goes to a final vote or, even with all of these amendments, the Bill will struggle to reach 60 votes I fear.

Mr. President, the majority has the votes to bring this bill to the floor. It doesn't have the votes to pass it alone. I'm offering a hand, not a fist. Accept these amendments and find the money without borrowing, and I believe you'll find Republicans ready to help build every road, bridge and port in every corner of this country.

I yield the floor.
 
Back
Top