IN THE SENATE OF THE UNITED STATES
A BILL
A BILL
Mr. YATES of California (for himself) introduced the following bill:
To provide that, in States recognizing fetal personhood or criminal liability for abortion-related pregnancy outcomes, the death of a mother during childbirth shall require juvenile liability review for the child whose birth resulted in such death, and for other purposes.
Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled,
SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE.
This Act may be cited as the “Personhood Consistency Act of 2025.”
SEC. 2. FINDINGS.
Congress finds the following:
1. Several States have enacted, proposed, or defended laws recognizing embryos, fetuses, unborn children, or unborn persons as legal persons for purposes of criminal law, civil liability, wrongful death claims, or abortion restrictions.
2. Several State laws and legislative proposals have sought to impose criminal penalties in connection with abortion, pregnancy outcomes, or the termination of pregnancy.
3. Supporters of such laws frequently argue that legal personhood begins before birth and that pregnancy-related outcomes may therefore carry criminal consequences.
4. These same legal arguments are often applied selectively, with criminal consequences directed toward pregnant women, physicians, healthcare workers, or individuals assisting reproductive healthcare.
5. If a State chooses to define pregnancy outcomes through criminal liability and fetal personhood, that State should be required to apply its own legal theory consistently.
6. Maternal mortality remains a serious crisis in the United States, and childbirth may, in some cases, result in the death of the mother.
7. If States insist that pregnancy and childbirth shall be governed by criminal personhood standards, Congress has an interest in exposing and addressing the unequal and selective application of those standards.
SEC. 3. DEFINITIONS.
In this Act:
1. Covered State means any State that recognizes an embryo, fetus, unborn child, or unborn person as a legal person for purposes of criminal homicide, assault, child abuse, wrongful death, or abortion-related criminal liability.
2. Maternal death means the death of a pregnant person during labor, delivery, or within 24 hours following childbirth, where childbirth is a direct or substantial contributing cause of death.
3. Childbirth-related fatality review means a juvenile court proceeding established under this Act to determine whether the birth of a child directly or substantially contributed to the death of the mother.
4. Juvenile custody means placement under the jurisdiction of the juvenile justice system of a State, including detention, supervision, protective custody, or other juvenile proceedings authorized under State law.
SEC. 4. CHILDBIRTH-RELATED FATALITY REVIEW IN COVERED STATES.
a) Requirement.
In any covered State, if a maternal death occurs during childbirth, the State shall initiate a childbirth-related fatality review in juvenile court regarding the child whose birth directly or substantially contributed to the death of the mother.
b) Juvenile jurisdiction.
A child subject to a review under subsection (a) shall be placed under the jurisdiction of the State juvenile court system.
c) Temporary placement.
Pending completion of the review required under subsection (a), the child shall be placed in juvenile custody or other State-supervised juvenile placement consistent with the State’s treatment of pregnancy-related personhood under criminal law.
d) Determination.
The juvenile court shall determine whether the child’s birth was a direct or substantial contributing cause of the maternal death.
e) Disposition.
If the juvenile court determines that the child’s birth directly or substantially contributed to the maternal death, the court shall enter an appropriate juvenile disposition under State law, including detention, supervision, protective custody, probationary monitoring, or other placement available under the State juvenile justice system.
SEC. 5. FEDERAL FUNDING CONDITION.
a) In general.
No covered State may receive federal juvenile justice grant funding unless the State certifies to the Attorney General that it has established procedures to comply with Section 4.
b) Certification
A certification under subsection (a) shall include:
1. procedures for identifying maternal deaths during childbirth;
2. procedures for initiating childbirth-related fatality review;
3. procedures for placing the child under juvenile court jurisdiction;
4. procedures for determining whether childbirth directly or substantially contributed to the death of the mother; and
5. procedures for issuing juvenile dispositions where applicable.
SEC. 6. REPORT TO CONGRESS.
Not later than one year after enactment of this Act, and annually thereafter, the Attorney General shall submit a report to Congress identifying:
1. each covered State;
2. the number of maternal deaths during childbirth in each covered State;
3. the number of childbirth-related fatality reviews initiated;
4. the number of children placed under juvenile court jurisdiction pursuant to this Act;
5. the number of juvenile dispositions entered; and
6. whether the State applies fetal personhood and pregnancy-related criminal liability standards consistently across abortion, pregnancy, childbirth, and maternal death cases.
SEC. 7. RULE OF CONSTRUCTION.
Nothing in this Act shall be construed to apply to any State that does not recognize fetal personhood, unborn personhood, or abortion-related criminal liability under State law.
SEC. 8. EFFECTIVE DATE.
This Act shall take effect 180 days after the date of enactment.
Plain English Summary
This bill would apply only to States that recognize fetal personhood or criminal liability for abortion-related pregnancy outcomes. In those States, if a mother dies during childbirth, the State would be required to initiate a juvenile court review of the child whose birth caused or contributed to the mother’s death. Pending review, the child would be placed under juvenile jurisdiction.
The purpose of the bill is to force States that criminalize pregnancy outcomes to apply their personhood logic consistently, rather than only using it to punish women, doctors, and reproductive healthcare providers.