FOR IMMEDIATE RELEASE
Office of United States Senator Sarah Johansen (R-IA)
Senator Johansen Statement on the Nomination of Judge Sri Srinivasan to the Supreme Court of the United States

WASHINGTON, D.C. — United States Senator Sarah Johansen (R-IA) today announced that, after careful review of the nomination hearing and the full record of Judge Sri Srinivasan, she will oppose his confirmation to serve as an Associate Justice of the Supreme Court of the United States.
“The decision to cast a vote on a lifetime appointment to the Supreme Court is among the most solemn responsibilities entrusted to a Member of the Senate,” Senator Johansen said. “It requires more than an assessment of intellect or professional accomplishment. It demands a judgment about whether the nominee’s approach to the law, as demonstrated over a career of advocacy and judging, will strengthen the constitutional order and protect the rights of ordinary citizens. After examining the record in detail, I have concluded that I cannot in good conscience support this nomination.”
Senator Johansen outlined several specific areas of concern that emerged during the hearing and in the nominee’s prior work:
Advocacy on Corporate Liability under the Alien Tort Statute
As counsel for Exxon Mobil in
John Doe VIII v. Exxon Mobil Corp., Judge Srinivasan advanced the position that corporations are categorically immune from civil liability under the Alien Tort Statute, even in cases involving allegations of extrajudicial killings, torture, sexual assault, and other serious human rights abuses. He later sought rehearing after the D.C. Circuit rejected that argument. Similar positions were taken on behalf of other corporate clients in related litigation. While every party is entitled to vigorous representation, the consistent advancement of categorical corporate immunity in the face of grave allegations raises legitimate questions about how a Justice Srinivasan would approach questions of accountability when the interests of powerful institutions are at stake. The distinction between advocate and judge is real and important; the record must still be weighed when a nominee seeks a seat on the nation’s highest Court.
The Watters v. Wachovia Brief and Preemption of State Consumer Protections
While serving in the Office of the Solicitor General, Judge Srinivasan participated in the preparation of the United States’ brief in
Watters v. Wachovia Bank. That brief urged the Supreme Court to hold that federal law preempted Michigan’s authority to regulate the mortgage-lending activities of a national bank’s operating subsidiary. In doing so, the brief dismissed the state’s consumer-protection concerns as “beside the point” and relied on an Office of the Comptroller of the Currency finding that there was “no reason to believe that [abusive] practices are occurring in the national banking system to any significant degree.”
That assertion was made in November 2006. Within a short time, the housing crisis inflicted severe hardship on families across Michigan and the nation. Judge Srinivasan has acknowledged that the agency’s factual claim proved incorrect. Yet the episode remains troubling. It reflects a willingness to elevate federal preemption and agency assertions over the practical capacity of states to safeguard their residents from predatory lending practices. The brief’s treatment of consumer interests, and the subsequent human cost of the financial crisis, cannot be set aside as mere historical footnote when evaluating fitness for the Supreme Court.
Broader Pattern of Advocacy and the Role of a Justice
The nominee’s career includes representation of Jeffrey Skilling in connection with the Enron scandal and repeated advocacy on behalf of large corporate clients in high-stakes matters. An attorney’s duty to a client is fundamental to our adversarial system, and no one should be denied counsel. At the same time, a Justice of the Supreme Court does not continue the work of the advocate. The Court must decide cases according to the Constitution and the laws enacted by Congress, without regard to the identity or power of the parties. The hearing did not sufficiently allay concerns that the nominee’s long record of advancing the most aggressive available corporate positions may influence the institutional instincts he would bring to the bench.
Senator Johansen emphasized that her opposition is not rooted in personal animus or partisan calculation. “Judge Srinivasan is a highly capable lawyer and jurist with a compelling personal story. He has served under administrations of both parties and has answered questions with care and professionalism. Those facts are not in dispute. What remains in dispute is whether this particular record marked by repeated efforts to limit corporate accountability under the Alien Tort Statute, to preempt state consumer protections in the years preceding the housing crisis, and to advance positions that consistently favored institutional power provides adequate assurance that he will approach the great questions of our time with the necessary independence and regard for the rights of ordinary Americans.”
“The seat to which Judge Srinivasan has been nominated once belonged to Justice Antonin Scalia, a jurist who insisted that the words of the Constitution and of statutes mean what they say and that judges are not free to rewrite them according to preferred policy outcomes. Filling that seat requires a Justice who will exercise similar discipline. After full consideration of the hearing and the underlying record, I am not persuaded that confirming Judge Srinivasan would best serve that standard, the Constitution, or the people of Iowa. I will therefore vote against this nomination.”