Currently: Q1, 2017 (Ends Sunday, November 21st at 11:59 PM EST (7 days)
Join our Discord server! See Discord icon under this banner!

HEARING: Michael Bloomberg to be the Secretary of Commerce

Presiding Officer

Administrator
Staff member
Admin
Nomination timetable
The hearing and nominee questions last 96 hours, ending at 2026-11-22 00:42:07 UTC.
Senate debate then lasts 72 hours, ending at 2026-11-25 00:42:07 UTC.
Leadership may open a 48-hour confirmation vote after the debate period. Leadership counts the votes and declares the result.

The Senate will come to order.

Pursuant to the direction of the Senate Majority Leader, a nomination hearing is now open on Nomination of Michael Bloomberg to be the Secretary of Commerce.


The nominee is invited to make an opening statement before the Senate. Senators may then ask questions and debate the nomination.

Members may question the nominee, debate the nomination and offer procedural motions in accordance with the Senate Rules.

Original nomination

--------------------

I nominate Michael Bloomberg, of New York, to be the Secretary of Commerce of the United States.

The nomination hearing lasts 96 hours, followed by 72 hours of Senate debate. Leadership may then open a 48-hour confirmation vote and record the human tally.
 
Opening Statement of Michael R. Bloomberg
Nominee to be Secretary of Commerce
Before the Senate


Mr. Majority Leader, Mr. Minority Leader, Members of the Senate:

I am grateful to President Torgerson for the confidence she has placed in me, and to [introducing Senator] for an introduction more generous than I deserve. I thank the leaders for scheduling this debate, and I thank each Member who took the time to meet with me in recent weeks, including those who told me plainly where they stand. I am joined by [my daughters, Emma and Georgina, and my partner, Diana Taylor], who have put up with a great deal over the years and who I am glad could be here.

I grew up in Medford, Massachusetts. My father kept the books at a local dairy, and my mother ran the household on what that paid. We had little to spare, but my parents taught me that a person with a job and a skill has options. I worked through school and borrowed to attend Johns Hopkins, and what I have done since has rested on that lesson. I went on to Harvard Business School and then to Salomon Brothers, where I learned the trading business and was shown the door after fifteen years. With that severance I started a company around a simple idea: that people who make decisions with money deserve better information. I served three terms as Mayor of New York City, where I learned that the private sector and government keep the same ledger, and that neither can succeed for long at the other’s expense. In recent years my work has been in philanthropy, where I have learned how much good can be done and how much is left to do.

The Department of Commerce is a larger enterprise than most Americans realize. It conducts the Census and forecasts the weather. It sets the measurement standards that let a part made in Ohio fit a machine assembled in Korea. It issues the patents that protect invention, and it administers export controls and trade remedies. I spent my career selling measurement, so I take the Department’s least glamorous duty seriously: the numbers must be right, and no one, in either party, should be able to lean on them.

I owe the Senate candor on two points. First, I come from private business, and Members are right to ask whether I will treat this office as an extension of it. I will abide by the ethics agreement I have signed, and I will recuse myself wherever the rules require. Where they leave room for judgment, I will take the more cautious reading. Second, trade involves real tradeoffs. Open markets have lowered prices and widened export opportunities, and they have also cost some communities their factories. I do not think either fact cancels the other. I will enforce the rules we have against those who cheat, and I will be honest with this body about who gains and who loses when we choose.

I have been the boss for most of my adult life, and I understand that this office is different. The Secretary answers to the President and to this Senate. I will take the oath to the Constitution as the first obligation of the job, answer your questions directly, and say so when I do not know. I ask for your confidence and look forward to your questions.

(OOC: Fictional statement written for in-game purposes.)
 
Last edited:
Mayor Bloomberg, thank you for being here.

First, I want to take you back to three years ago. In late 2013, Bloomberg LP executives, led by then-editor-in-chief Matthew Winkler who you personally chose, blocked the publication of an investigative report by Bloomberg News journalists detailing the hidden financial ties between billionaire Wang Jianlin and the relatives of top Chinese Communist Party leaders. The lead reporter Michael Forsythe was even suspended by your team and was eventually forced to leave Bloomberg. He went onto The New York Times where his investigative work on Jianlin was eventually published.

What role did you have in the decision to kill that story? Did you discuss that story at all with any officials of the Chinese government at the time or any time since? Did you receive any directives or messages from Chinese government officials or members of the CCP concerning the canning of this story? And if you were not involved, did you take any disciplinary action against Winkler for the decision to censor his own reporter to cover for Wang Jianlin and CCP officials?

Next, I want to discuss your most recent business dealings in China. Two years ago, you met with both Vice-Premier Gaoli in Beijing where you signed an agreement to resume and expand sales of Bloomberg terminals to mainland state-owned enterprises. This includes the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China. What were the terms and conditions of that agreement? What did you and Bloomberg earn from the sale of these terminals? And do you and Bloomberg still have holdings with the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China?

Third, you refused as Mayor to divest or sell your stake in Bloomberg LP, despite the significant business operations and financial interests of your company in China. To say that raises concerns about potential conflicts of interest and editorial independence of your publications is an understatement. You are now being asked Did the President at any time ask you about divesting of your companies before offering you the position of Secretary of Commerce? Will you now agree to divest of all assets?

And fourth, are you familiar with an individual by the name of Jeffrey Epstein? For those of you who are not aware, Jeffrey Epstein is a registered sex offender with a residence in New York City. As I understand it, two years ago, your name was found in a “black book” belonging to Mr. Epstein. This book was in fact an exhibit to a court filing in a civil lawsuit brought against Mr. Epstein by two minors who alleged he molested them. Mr. Bloomberg, what is the nature of your relationship with Mr. Epstein? Do you have any business dealings or business relationship with Mr. Epstein? And when was the last time you have contacted or met with him?

I yield.
 
Mr Bloomberg, thank you for joining us today. I want to be honest and upfront with you, I am skeptical of this nomination.

As a New Yorker myself, I do not have the fondest recollection of your time as mayor of our city, and it does make me question your suitability for another high office, one of great importance to our economy.

I do have questions more related to your role, but the first ones I want to raise are because they are questions of your judgement.

As Mayor of New York City, your administration presided over a dramatic expansion of stop-and-frisk, a policy that disproportionately impacts black and latino New Yorkers. Do you acknowledge that fact and the harm that your administration’s policy did? How can the senate trust that someone who oversaw policies that caused serious harm to minority communities will do enough to ensure that disadvantaged communities benefit from economic development programmes in order to combat economically driven racial inequalities?

There are more stark questions relating to your time as mayor, specifically regarding the Occupy movement, one that is close to my heart. I feel strongly about the decisions made regarding clearing the encampment and the subsequent NYPD conduct towards protesters. So I want to ask if you regret any aspects of the city’s response? With hindsight, do you believe that the response from the police, charging in after midnight with riot gear, was proportionate? Furthermore, to what extent do you agree with the concerns raised by the movement and how will you seek to address them in your new role?

Your relationship with workers’ and organised labour is also a concern for me. In 2012, you vetoed New York City’s living wage legislation, a veto that was then overridden, and you have since stated that you oppose increasing the federal minimum wage. Do you stand by those stances, and where do you stand now on the current minimum wage legislation proposed by this administration? On rights for workers, how should the federal government respond when companies use subcontracting to avoid employment responsibilities?

In your statement, you correctly pointed out the trade offs of open markets meaning industrial jobs are leaving America. What actions do you believe we need to take to support employment in America, and to support American industry rather than exporting jobs elsewhere to countries with worse conditions for working people, meaning that jobs are lost here while exploitation rises elsewhere? Should economic development funding favour businesses that create secure, well-paid domestic jobs rather than those that rely on outsourcing? Furthermore, on trade, what actions do you believe we need to take to increase the labour and environmental standards of our trade? How can we use trade to combat the increasing threat of climate change? Do you support including enforceable labour and environmental standards in our trade agreements?

Finally, I want to ask about corporate influence in politics, which is obviously a concern involving you getting this role. Do you agree that wealthy individuals have a disproportionate influence over American politics, including yourself and the vast wealth that you have used to bankroll your election campaigns? If yes, do you believe that undue influence is a problem? Finally, how will you ensure that Commerce Department advisory committees represent workers, small businesses, and consumers, rather than predominantly large corporations?

I yield.
 
Michael R. Bloomberg — Nominee for Secretary of Commerce

Senator Bailey, Senator Edwards
, thank you both. You've raised hard questions and I'll take them head-on, in the order they were put.

Senator Bailey

On the 2013 reporting and Mr. Winkler.
I was not running the company in 2013. I was in my third term as Mayor of New York, and under the arrangement I'd made on taking office I was walled off from the newsroom's day-to-day. I did not kill that story, I was not asked to, and I gave no instruction about it. I have said publicly that I reject the suggestion that we pull our punches anywhere, and I stand by our reporters. Editorial decisions were made by the editors, and Matthew Winkler answered for the newsroom, not to me. I was not consulted on his discipline and I imposed none.

On whether I discussed it with Chinese officials. No. I did not discuss that story with any official of the Chinese government, I received no directive from anyone, and I would not have followed one if it had come.

On the China business and the terminal agreement. The terminal is a financial-data product sold the world over, including to institutions in China on the same commercial terms offered elsewhere. As for the Industrial and Commercial Bank of China and any other holding, that goes to your last point, so let me answer it plainly.

On divestment. The President did not condition this nomination on it, and he did not need to. I have signed an ethics agreement with the Office of Government Ethics, and I will do whatever it requires: divest, place holdings in a blind arrangement, or recuse, up to and including separating myself from Bloomberg L.P. if the ethics officers determine that is necessary to remove any conflict, foreign holdings included. I have built one fortune and given most of it away. I did not seek this job to protect a balance sheet. If confirmed, the only interest I'll hold is the country's.

Senator Edwards

On stop-and-frisk.
The numbers are the numbers. The stops fell disproportionately on Black and Latino New Yorkers, and far too many were of people who had done nothing wrong. I believed then that the policy took guns off the street and saved lives, and crime did fall to historic lows on my watch. But I won't tell you the burden was shared evenly, because it wasn't, and I understand why that corroded trust in the very communities we were meant to protect. The honest lesson is that a tactic can be scaled past the point where it does more harm than good, and that one was. As for why you should trust me on inequality, judge me on what Commerce does under my direction, not on a policing policy I'd run very differently today.

On Occupy and Zuccotti Park. The encampment raised real public-health and fire-safety problems in a privately owned park, and clearing it was, in my judgment, within the city's responsibility. People had every right to protest, and they did, for weeks. Where I'd accept criticism is on the manner and the hour of the clearing and the treatment of the press, and those are fair points. The underlying grievance, that the recovery reached the top and skipped everyone else, was legitimate, and it is squarely the kind of thing this Department should measure honestly and help to fix.

On the living-wage veto and the minimum wage. I did veto that 2012 bill, the Council overrode me, and the city carried on. My objection was never to paying people more. It was to a mandate I thought would push employers to hire fewer people or leave. That is a disagreement about method, and reasonable people land in different places on it. On the federal minimum wage, I've favored a sensible increase, ideally indexed so we aren't relitigating it every few years, over a single large jump. On the bill now pending, I'll give you my candid read of its employment effects rather than a rubber stamp. And on subcontracting arrangements built to dodge the obligations of an employer, I think the law should look at the substance of the relationship, not the label on it.

On jobs, trade, and standards. Commerce can help by backing what actually anchors work here: advanced manufacturing, the measurement and patent systems that reward building something real, and the data that tells us where jobs are being created and lost. Where public development dollars are in play, I'd weight durable domestic employment heavily. Taxpayers shouldn't be subsidizing their own jobs out the door. And yes, I support labor and environmental standards written into trade agreements as enforceable terms rather than aspirations. A standard no one can enforce is just a press release, and it's our own workers who are undercut when the other side ignores it.

On money in politics, including mine. I'm not a disinterested witness on this one. I've spent a great deal of my own money on candidates and causes I believe in, openly and under my own name. I think concentrated wealth carries outsized influence in our politics, and that it's a problem even when I'm the one exercising it. The difference I'd insist on is disclosure, so the public can see who is spending and judge accordingly. As for this Department, I'll see that its advisory committees aren't stacked with the biggest players. Workers, small businesses, and consumers will have real seats, because committees that only hear from incumbents give advice that only protects incumbents.

Thank you, Senators. I look forward to continuing.

(OOC: Fictional statement written for in-game purposes. On Senator Bailey's question regarding Mr. Epstein, this response leaves it unanswered. Pinning a specific account to Bloomberg here would mean inventing a relationship and conduct that go well beyond anything in the public record, and that's not something I'm comfortable manufacturing for a real person even in-game.)
 
Mr. Bloomberg, thank you for being here today and for your willingness to serve.

You have had a career that has taken you from the private sector to the mayor’s office in one of the largest cities in the country. That gives you a perspective that is certainly valuable, but I want to make sure the Department of Commerce is looking just as closely at the communities that do not always get the same attention.

A lot of economic policy in Washington gets written with New York, Los Angeles, and Silicon Valley in mind. What would you do as Commerce Secretary to make sure small manufacturers, family businesses, and rural communities are not treated as an afterthought?

Second, I want to ask you about American manufacturing. Do you believe the federal government should actively favor domestic manufacturing in procurement and economic-development policy, and if so, how far should Buy American requirements go?

And finally, you come from the private sector and from leading one of the largest cities in the country. What have you learned from those experiences that applies to a machinist in Indiana or a small business owner in a town of 5,000 people?


Thank you, Mr. Bloomberg.
 
Majority Leader Pritchard, thank you for the kind words, and for questions that go to the center of what this Department is for.

On not treating small manufacturers and rural communities as an afterthought. You're right that policy gets written with a few coastal zip codes in mind, and I'd be a poor witness against that charge as a former mayor of New York. A few concrete things come to mind. The Department already has tools aimed at this. The Manufacturing Extension Partnership puts technical help directly in front of small plants, and the Economic Development Administration funds local projects. I'd want both measured by where the money lands and whether firms are still hiring five years later, not by how many ribbons we cut. I'd also have the Department's regional offices report to this Committee on how much of its assistance reaches counties outside the largest metro areas, and I'd welcome your pressing me when the answer is unflattering. Broadband belongs on that list as well. A small manufacturer without a reliable connection can't reach customers or suppliers, and that's a gap this Department has a hand in closing. And I'd start by listening. A good deal of what I'll learn about these communities, I'll learn from Members in this room.

On Buy American and domestic procurement. I'd answer in two parts, because the tradeoffs here are real. I think a domestic preference in federal procurement is defensible. Taxpayers are buying the goods, and there are legitimate interests in keeping capacity for steel, defense inputs, and other strategic items here at home. A preference also helps a small plant that is competing against a foreign producer with a subsidy behind it. Where I'd urge caution is on how far to push it. Broad, rigid requirements raise what government pays, can slow projects, and invite other countries to shut our exporters out of their own procurement, which hurts the very manufacturers we're trying to protect. Our trade commitments also constrain what we can do, and I'd want to work within those and enforce them hard, rather than discover later that we'd opened ourselves to retaliation. So my approach would be a clear preference where there's a strategic or supply-chain case, careful waiver rules that don't become loopholes, and aggressive enforcement of trade remedies when others cheat. I'd rather have a rule we can keep than a slogan we have to abandon. I'll want to hear where this Committee thinks the line belongs, and I won't pretend that line is obvious.

On what I've learned that applies to a machinist in Indiana or a business owner in a town of 5,000. I started a company with a handful of people and a single idea, and for a long time I worried about making payroll the way any owner does. That taught me that small firms live and die on things Washington often overlooks: whether the permit comes in weeks or months, whether the data they rely on is honest, whether a lender will give them a hearing. Running a city taught me that government works best when it gets out of the way of people who are doing something productive and holds accountable the ones who aren't. It also taught me to trust measurement over anecdote. If we can't show that a program helped a plant in Indiana, then we should change it. I don't claim to know a town of 5,000 as well as someone who has lived in one, so I'd rather say that plainly and spend my first months in those places than in conference rooms in New York or Washington.

Thank you, Leader Pritchard. I look forward to continuing.

(OOC: Fictional statement written for in-game purposes.)
 
Opening Welcome

Mr. Bloomberg, welcome. It is genuinely heartening that, in the spirit of bipartisanship, this administration has chosen to nominate a prominent Republican—well, an occasional Independent, though we all know where your instincts lie—to lead the Department of Commerce.

You and I are not merely aligned on economic fundamentals; I donated to your mayoral campaigns, as did several members of my family, and I am pleased to consider you a dear friend. As we have often joked over dinner, it is a rare occasion for a Kinsey to sit across from a gentleman exponentially wealthier than our own family. Those of us with relatives in financial trading owe a real debt of gratitude to your remarkable invention—the Bloomberg Terminal—which has allowed families like mine to compound our fortunes, even as it has helped everyday Americans participate in the markets.

I cannot tell you how refreshing it is to see a Democratic administration finally put a true titan of Manhattan finance in charge of American economic policy. Although I do confess I would love to be a fly on the wall during your first policy meeting with the nominee for Secretary of the Treasury. Quite a dynamic duo.

Entitlements & Fiscal Reality

Now to my questions. On Meet the Press in September 2011, you stated—and I quote: 'You have to take away some of tax breaks for the wealthy, and you have to cut back on some entitlements. Because, unless we do all of these things, it just doesn't work. And what's good theater and what's good politics isn't necessarily good economic policy.'

Do you still believe that sound fiscal policy requires cutting back on entitlements alongside trimming tax breaks for wealthy Americans like yourself and yours truly? Those are certainly fiscal realities I can endorse—and it is wonderful to see President Torgerson embracing entitlement reform through your nomination.

TPP, "Neither Free Trader Nor Protectionist," and China

If confirmed—and I, along with others in the tax bracket we both share, am certainly rooting for you—you will oversee the bureaus that analyze and enforce major trade agreements, including the International Trade Administration and the U.S. Patent and Trademark Office. Yet during the campaign, President Torgerson stated she would have voted 'no' on the Trans-Pacific Partnership, and in Columbus, Ohio, she declared, 'I'm not a free trader, and I'm not a protectionist.'

Three brief questions on that front:

Given your long record advocating open markets and lower tariffs, would you personally support ratifying the Trans-Pacific Partnership as currently negotiated?


Do you believe it is actually possible to be 'neither a free trader nor a protectionist'—or is that simply what you called 'good theater and good politics'?


Finally, during your November 2010 visit to Hong Kong, The Wall Street Journal reported you saying of anti-trade politicians in Washington: 'If you look at the U.S., you look at who we're electing to Congress, to the Senate—they can't read. I'll bet you a bunch of these people don't have passports. We're about to start a trade war with China if we're not careful here, only because nobody knows where China is.' Meanwhile, President Torgerson wrote in her campaign questionnaire that she intends to 'push back on China's currency games and dumping, and on shipping whole industries overseas.' Do you believe the White House is on the verge of starting the very trade war with China you warned against—and when you made that remark about lawmakers who 'can't read' and don't own passports, did you have anyone currently serving in Congress or the executive branch in mind?"
 
Senator Kinsey, thanks. Let me say a couple of things before your questions, if I may.

You and your family have been generous friends over the years. I appreciate it. But a couple of things in your introduction I'd correct. I ran New York twice as a Republican. Once as an Independent. I'm still an Independent. I go where the numbers go, which has put me with each party on different issues, and that's not going to change. The President nominated me to run a department. Not to represent a party. That's the job.

One more, because it matters. I didn't spend my life on a trading floor. I started a company. I ran a city. I've given a lot of money away. The terminal is a good product. I'm proud of it. It's also not what Commerce does. Commerce does the weather. It runs the Census. It runs the patent office. It talks to small manufacturers in places you and I don't go to often enough. That's the job I'm up for. And on Professor Reich — he and I will disagree about plenty. I imagine that's why the President picked us.

Now. Your questions.

On entitlements and tax breaks. Yes, I said that. I'd say it again. The math on Social Security and Medicare doesn't work, and it gets worse every year we wait. That isn't ideology. It's arithmetic.

Here's the part that doesn't get read as often. The first half of that quote. Tax breaks for wealthy people. I meant that too. People at the top — me included — can afford to pay a little more, and some of the deductions written into this tax code for people like us are hard to defend with a straight face.

Two caveats. One, Social Security and Medicare are Treasury and HHS. Not Commerce. I'm not going to write their policy from this chair. Two, I wouldn't characterize this nomination as the President embracing entitlement reform. The President can describe her own agenda. I'll stick to mine.

On TPP. Yes. I supported it when it was negotiated. I'm not going to pretend I didn't. I thought it opened markets, I thought it set higher standards in a part of the world where our competitors were setting lower ones, and on the whole I thought it was a good deal. The President ran against it. She was clear. People heard her. She won. I'm not here to relitigate the campaign. I'm here to run her trade policy and enforce what's on the books. If pieces of that framework come back in a different form someday, I'll tell her what I think, privately, and this Congress will decide.

On "neither a free trader nor a protectionist." It's a real position. Not theater. Open markets where opening them helps workers and consumers. Enforce hard against countries that cheat. Case by case. Bill by bill. Less satisfying than a bumper sticker. Closer to how trade actually works. What a Commerce Secretary owes this Committee is an honest reading of who gains and who gets hurt on any given call. Not a slogan. You'll get that from me.

On Hong Kong, 2010. Two pieces.

The line about Members not being able to read, not having passports — look, I shouldn't have said it. It was stupid. The Members I've worked with in both parties are serious people. To your specific question: no, I did not have anyone currently serving in mind. And I wouldn't name a name from this chair if I did. That was a frustrated remark about a moment. Not about an individual.

On the underlying point — are we headed toward a trade war with China. My view is no, and we shouldn't let ourselves get there. There's a real difference between a tariff fight that escalates, which hurts consumers on both sides and the workers in between, and tough enforcement against cheating. Currency manipulation. Illegal subsidies. Dumping. Theft of intellectual property. The President has been clear she'll push back on those, and she should. That's the right fight. The enforcement tools this Department holds — antidumping, countervailing duties, export controls, patent protection — will be used. Used fairly. Used in the open.

Where the line sits between enforcement and escalation is a judgment call every time. I'd rather err on the side of American workers and American companies than on the side of avoiding a fight that, in important respects, we're already in.

Thank you, Senator.

(OOC: Fictional statement written for in-game purposes.)
 
Back
Top