Reeves to face early choices on reshaping federal judiciary
Judicial | 2024
WASHINGTON, D.C. – With a new presidential administration taking office, attention is already turning toward one of the most enduring legacies any president can leave behind: the judges they appoint.
Although major Supreme Court vacancies often dominate public attention, legal analysts note that the overwhelming majority of a president's influence comes through appointments to the circuit courts, where many more cases are decided every year and where future Supreme Court precedents are often born.
"The judiciary is one of the few areas where a president's decisions can shape public policy for a generation or more," legal analyst Alexis Dunn said. "Every administration enters office with the same fundamental question: How aggressively do you want to reshape the courts?"
If the president's party also controls the Senate, analysts say the administration generally has several strategic options.
Some White Houses pursue a consensus strategy. These administrations typically favor institutionalists, centrists, minimalists, legal formalists, pragmatists, technocrats, and, on occasion, statists whose deference to established institutions is viewed as promoting stability. These judges are generally regarded as highly qualified, methodical, and unlikely to generate sustained confirmation battles. While this approach often leads to faster confirmations, it usually produces only incremental changes to the long-term ideological direction of the judiciary.
Others adopt a mainstream ideological strategy, nominating judges who clearly reflect the administration's constitutional philosophy while remaining within the legal mainstream. Conservative administrations often emphasize originalists, textualists, legal formalists, and traditionalists, while liberal administrations may favor progressives, pragmatists, living constitutionalists, and institutionalists. More unconventional philosophies, such as libertarians or populists, may occasionally be nominated when they possess strong professional credentials and are viewed as broadly confirmable. Although confirmation fights become more common, these nominees are generally regarded as professionally qualified and philosophically consistent rather than overtly movement-oriented.
Administrations adopting a transformational strategy seek to reshape constitutional doctrine for generations by appointing judges with distinctive and influential judicial philosophies. Conservative presidents may build a bench around originalists, textualists, libertarians, strict constructionists, and traditionalists, while liberal presidents often look to living constitutionalists, progressives, judicial activists, and pragmatists capable of expanding constitutional protections or rethinking existing precedent. Some administrations also elevate technocrats or institutionalists when they believe lasting change can be achieved through methodological consistency rather than ideological confrontation, while others occasionally embrace populists whose skepticism of entrenched institutions aligns with the administration's broader political vision. These nominations frequently become the most closely watched confirmation battles of a presidency.
Finally, some presidents embrace a maximum confrontation strategy, deliberately nominating highly ideological or movement-oriented jurists despite anticipating fierce political resistance. These administrations seek nominees whose judicial philosophies unmistakably embody the president's constitutional vision. Conservative administrations may elevate strict constructionists, originalists, libertarians, or traditionalists with records of challenging established doctrine, while liberal administrations may nominate judicial activists, living constitutionalists, or outspoken progressives prepared to reconsider long-settled precedent in pursuit of broader constitutional protections. In rare cases, presidents may also nominate particularly outspoken populists or statists whose judicial records closely reflect the administration's governing philosophy, even when doing so guarantees an exceptionally contentious confirmation process. Such nominations often energize the president's political base but consume significant political capital and can result in prolonged confirmation battles.
Judicial nomination strategies have varied considerably across recent administrations.
Legal analysts generally characterize President Bill Clinton's approach as emphasizing broadly confirmable center-left nominees, while President George W. Bush more consistently selected judges with established conservative judicial philosophies. President Barack Obama largely continued a mainstream ideological approach centered on pragmatists and institutionalists, whereas President Donald Trump placed an unusual emphasis on judicial appointments, pursuing what analysts describe as a more transformational strategy built around originalists and textualists. President Joe Biden has largely followed a mainstream ideological model while also elevating a number of nominees whose judicial philosophies could shape constitutional doctrine for years to come.
Analysts caution that these strategies are not mutually exclusive. Most administrations employ a blend of approaches depending on the court involved, the political makeup of the Senate, and the importance of a particular vacancy.
The degree of presidential involvement also varies from administration to administration. Some presidents take a personal interest in individual nominees, while others delegate much of the selection process to the Vice President, other senior advisors, or the White House Counsel after establishing the broader judicial philosophy they want reflected on the federal bench.
While the White House decides how aggressively to reshape the judiciary, Senate leaders decide how aggressively to resist those efforts.
Under a cooperative strategy, the Senate processes most nominees in a large bloc, reserving opposition for exceptional cases. Judicial vacancies continue to be filled at a relatively steady pace, even under divided government.
Some Senate majorities instead adopt an aggressive obstruction strategy, slowing confirmations through delays, considering them one at a time, putting up other procedural hurdles, and extended floor consideration. Vacancies begin to accumulate.
At its most confrontational, a Senate majority may pursue a maximum resistance strategy, advancing only nominees viewed as exceptionally moderate or politically unavoidable while attempting to leave many vacancies unfilled until after the next presidential election.
Legal analysts caution that these strategic decisions often shape the judiciary long after the political debates surrounding individual nominees have faded.
"Presidents serve four years," Dunn said. "Federal judges often serve thirty or forty. That's why the first months of a new administration can become some of the most consequential for the future direction of American law."