Currently: Q1, 2017 (Ends Sunday, November 21st at 11:59 PM EST (7 days)
Join our Discord server! See Discord icon under this banner!

Court blocks Reeves from shutting down legal port-of-entry processing

Brink

Member
Player Media
US_Dist_S_Cal.jpg
Court blocks Reeves from shutting down legal port-of-entry processing
Judicial | Q1, 2025​

SAN DIEGO, CALIFORNIA – A unanimous three judge panel of the Ninth Circuit Court today temporarily blocked part of President Liam Reeves's (R-South Carolina) sweeping United States-Mexico border executive order, ruling that the administration may not categorically refuse to inspect and process people who present themselves at legal ports of entry while a challenge to the order proceeds. The court left the remainder of Executive Order 0003 in effect.

The case was brought by Dr. Elena Marisol Vega, a Mexican physician who lives in Tijuana and works at a San Diego hospital under a valid H-1B visa. Vega alleged that federal officers refused to process her for admission after Reeves's order took effect, despite no allegation that she was otherwise inadmissible.

Under the injunction, federal officers must continue receiving, inspecting and processing people who present themselves at official southern ports of entry. The ruling does not require the government to admit those individuals and does not prevent officials from denying entry when federal law permits.

The injunction leaves intact the order's provisions concerning enforcement against illegal border crossings, lawful detention and removal, border barriers, personnel deployments, criminal prosecutions, parole policies and efforts to resume the Migrant Protection Protocols.

Today’s injunction ruling is only the opening salvo in the battle soon to come.

The same three judge panel will soon confront the broader question at the heart of Vega’s lawsuit: whether Reeves is lawfully using powers Congress gave the presidency, or whether Executive Order 0003 goes further by effectively rewriting immigration law and spending policy without Congress.

The administration is expected to argue that Congress gave the President broad authority under 8 U.S.C. §1182(f) to suspend or restrict the entry of noncitizens and that the order merely directs the executive branch to use existing immigration and border-security powers.

The panel that issued the injunction and will hear the full case is made up entirely of judges with progressive judicial philosophies: 78-year-old Benjamin Halpern, a Clinton appointee, and Biden appointees Jamie Mullins, 48, and Michael Beck, 45. Their ideological makeup could give Vega a potentially favorable bench as the case moves toward a fuller ruling on the legality of Reeves’s executive order.

“Today’s injunction does not tell us how the court will ultimately resolve the President’s authority to restrict entry, but it does show where this panel’s skepticism lies,” legal analyst Alexis Dunn said. “These judges appear unwilling to treat a broad grant of power over entry as permission to simply switch off immigration procedures Congress put in place, and that distinction could become the central fault line in the case.”

The injunction will remain in place while the court considers the broader challenge to the executive order. Once a ruling is made by the panel, the Reeves administration could seek relief from the Supreme Court or through en banc review of 11 judges sitting on the Ninth Circuit panel, where both sides are expected to argue over the limits of presidential authority in immigration enforcement and the extent to which Congress can constrain executive action at the border.

Whatever the final outcome, the case is shaping up to be one of the first major tests of Reeves’s use of executive power and an early indication of how aggressively the federal courts may scrutinize his immigration agenda.
 
Back
Top