Currently: Q1, 2017 (Ends Sunday, November 21st at 11:59 PM EST (7 days)
Join our Discord server! See Discord icon under this banner!

D.C. Circuit allows Reeves industrial strategy to proceed, says executive order creates no new presidential powers

Brink

Member
Player Media
iiif-service_pnp_highsm_42400_42434-full-pct_12.5-0-default.jpg
D.C. Circuit allows Reeves industrial strategy to proceed, says executive order creates no new presidential powers
Q2, 2025 | Judicial​

WASHINGTON, D.C. – A unanimous panel of the D.C. circuit court on Wednesday allowed President Liam Reeves’s (R-South Carolina) sweeping industrial strategy to remain in effect, rejecting a challenge from the National Association of Manufacturers (NAM).

The panel ruled 3-0 in National Association of Manufacturers v. Lighthizer, upholding Titles III, IV, XI, XII and XV of Executive Order 010, which established Operation American Affordability and directs agencies to coordinate industrial production, federal purchasing, financing, supply chain policy and regulatory reforms.

Chief Judge Margaret Holloway, an Obama appointee who is considered a centrist, wrote for the unanimous panel.

“The Executive Order may direct the exercise of lawful authority; it cannot create the authority it directs,” Holloway wrote.

NAM had argued that Reeves effectively created a nationwide industrial planning system without congressional approval, pointing to production goals, procurement preferences, financing priorities and directives spanning several Cabinet departments.

The court agreed that the order was “unquestionably ambitious” but found that its language repeatedly limits agencies to authorities they already possess under federal law.

“The Executive Order is unquestionably ambitious,” Holloway wrote. “It establishes national objectives for industrial production, procurement, investment, supply chains, and infrastructure and directs numerous executive agencies to coordinate their efforts toward those objectives. But a presidential directive identifying policy objectives is not itself an exercise of regulatory authority over private parties.”

Holloway relied heavily on the D.C. Circuit’s decision in Building & Construction Trades Department v. Allbaugh. In that case, the court held that a President may direct executive agencies in how they exercise existing statutory authority so long as an executive order does not independently create new powers.

EO 010 contains similar safeguards, including requirements that agencies act “to the maximum extent permitted by law,” remain within “existing statutory authorities,” and implement the order “consistent with applicable law.”

The panel also rejected NAM’s reliance on Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. v. Sawyer, distinguishing Reeves’s order from President Harry Truman’s attempted seizure of privately owned steel mills.

Executive Order 010, Holloway wrote, does not itself seize property, compel manufacturers to increase production or impose enforceable quotas.
But the ruling leaves the administration vulnerable to future lawsuits over how agencies actually implement the order.

The court said manufacturers could challenge a procurement condition, financing rule, production mandate or other agency action if officials cannot identify adequate congressional authorization. It similarly found NAM’s major questions argument premature because no specific agency action claiming extraordinary regulatory authority is currently before the court.

The 3-0 ruling brought together judges with notably different judicial approaches, though the opinion itself gives only limited insight into their individual reasoning.

Chief Judge Margaret Holloway, an Obama-appointed centrist, wrote the narrow opinion, allowing Reeves to coordinate executive policy while explicitly preserving future challenges to specific agency actions. Judge Jonathan Mercer, a legal formalist appointed by George H.W. Bush, and Judge Samuel Aldridge, a Trump-appointed institutionalist, joined without separate opinions.

Legal analyst Alexis Dunn said the unanimity should not be read as broad approval of Reeves’s economic powers.

“The important thing is what all three judges were willing to agree on: the executive order can stay, but it creates no new legal authority,” Dunn said. “That is a victory for Reeves with a very clear boundary around it.”

Dunn also said the ruling reflects the narrow posture of the case more than a definitive answer about the limits of Reeves’s industrial policy.

“NAM has a serious constitutional theory, but probably not the ideal case for presenting it,” Dunn said. “The D.C. Circuit didn't say Reeves can regulate the economy by decree. It said he can tell agencies to use powers Congress already gave them. The stronger Supreme Court case may come later, when one of those agencies actually does something NAM says Congress never authorized.”

The National Association of Manufacturers will have some time to seek further review. Its first option is to ask the full D.C Circuit to rehear the case en banc, a step that would cost 4 additional GPs. That request would not be granted automatically; a majority of the circuit’s judges would have to agree to reconsider the panel’s decision.

NAM could also bypass en banc review and petition the Supreme Court directly, also for 4 additional GPs. If the full D.C. Circuit declines rehearing, or accepts the case and later issues a new ruling, NAM would still retain the option of asking the Supreme Court to intervene.

Supreme Court review is discretionary. Four of the nine justices must vote to hear the case, and simply filing a petition would not suspend the Third Circuit’s ruling. The Court would separately decide whether to grant a stay if it accepts the dispute.

The Supreme Court will hear no more than four cases during a given in-game year. Petitions for review will be decided upon in the first quarter of 2026, with accepted cases decided during quarter two. Related disputes may also be heard together if they present the same legal question or produce a split among the federal circuits.
 
Back
Top