Currently: Q1, 2017 (Ends Sunday, November 21st at 11:59 PM EST (7 days)
Join our Discord server! See Discord icon under this banner!

Third Circuit panel allows Reeves's Operation Homefront order to stand, says Pennsylvania challenge is premature

Brink

Member
Player Media
Byrne-Courthouse-2.jpg
Third Circuit panel allows Reeves's Operation Homefront order to stand, says Pennsylvania challenge is premature
Q2, 2025 | Judicial​

PHILADELPHIA, PENNSYLVANIA – A three judge panel of the third circuit court on Friday rejected Pennsylvania’s challenge to President Liam Reeves’ housing executive order, concluding that the state went to court before the administration had taken concrete action that could be struck down.

In Pennsylvania v. Turner, the three-judge panel divided 2-1 over Title II of Executive Order 010, also known as Operation Homefront.

Judge Richard Callahan, writing for the majority, stressed the narrowness of the decision. The panel did not hold that the President possesses the power to rewrite local zoning laws, impose new conditions on federal grants, or override state building regulations. Callahan was appointed by former President George W. Bush (R-Texas) and is considered a textualist.

Instead, it concluded that the executive order itself does none of those things.

An order that directs, but does not itself regulate

Title II of the executive order orders federal agencies to “overhaul federal grant frameworks” to incentivize states and municipalities to remove restrictive zoning rules, develop federal certification pathways for certain forms of housing, and direct infrastructure funding toward housing development.

Pennsylvania argued that the provisions represented an attempt by the White House to nationalize an area of law traditionally controlled by states and local governments.

The majority disagreed with that characterization.

Central to its reasoning was language directing agencies to act “consistent with applicable law.”

Nothing in the order, Callahan explained, requires Pennsylvania to repeal a zoning ordinance. Nor does the order itself withdraw federal funding from states that decline to participate.

That distinction defeated Pennsylvania’s Tenth Amendment claim. Although the federal government cannot simply command state legislatures to enact or repeal laws, the majority concluded that Reeves has not yet done so.

The court similarly rejected Pennsylvania’s argument under Youngstown Sheet & Tube Co. v. Sawyer. Reeves has no inherent constitutional authority over local zoning, the majority acknowledged, but the executive order does not purport to give him one.

Instead, it instructs federal agencies to use whatever powers Congress has already given them.

“The Order therefore cannot itself enlarge HUD’s statutory powers,” Smith wrote.

Panel leaves major questions fight for another day

Pennsylvania also invoked the Supreme Court’s major questions doctrine, arguing that a nationwide effort to reshape zoning policy would require exceptionally clear congressional authorization.

But the majority concluded that the court does not yet know what authority the Department of Housing and Urban Development (HUD) will claim.

Only once an agency actually adopts a policy, identifies the statute supporting it, and attempts to enforce it will a court be positioned to determine whether Congress authorized the action.

The panel pointed to the Supreme Court’s 2024 decision in Loper Bright Enterprises v. Raimondo, emphasizing that courts will independently determine the scope of congressional delegations if HUD later claims sweeping authority.

The Spending Clause produced the majority’s strongest warning to the administration.

The 3rd Circuit previously held in City of Philadelphia v. Attorney General that the executive branch cannot create new conditions on federal grants without congressional authorization.

That precedent, the court suggested, could become a significant problem for Reeves if HUD eventually threatens existing housing funding unless states change their zoning laws.

But that has not happened yet.

The executive order, the majority emphasized, currently tells agencies to develop incentives rather than actually imposing a specific funding condition.

The court therefore affirmed the judgment for the administration without prejudice, meaning Pennsylvania can return to court if HUD later implements Operation Homefront in a manner the Commonwealth believes exceeds federal law.

Orlando: Court should not wait

Judge Thomas Orlando, one of the President’s recent appointees to the court, dissented.

Orlando rejected the majority’s characterization of the order as little more than preliminary executive planning.

“The President has ordered federal agencies to ‘overhaul federal grant frameworks’ for the express purpose of inducing States and municipalities to dismantle zoning laws,” he wrote.

For Orlando, the constitutional problem already exists.

The executive branch may administer grant conditions established by Congress, he argued, but cannot manufacture new conditions of its own. He also objected to the order’s direction that agencies develop mechanisms capable of “bypassing” local regulatory barriers.

Orlando was particularly dismissive of the administration’s reliance on the words “consistent with applicable law.”

“A President cannot issue an otherwise unlawful directive and immunize it from judicial review by appending the instruction that subordinates violate no laws while carrying it out,” he wrote.

He would have invalidated the challenged provisions insofar as they direct agencies to develop zoning related funding conditions or mechanisms circumventing state and local land use authority.

A victory with a conspicuous warning label

Legal analyst Alexis Dunn characterized the decision as less an endorsement of Reeves’s housing powers than a conclusion that the executive order has not actually done enough to create a justiciable constitutional violation.

“The majority is basically saying: there are a lot of words here, but where is the actionable law?” Dunn said. “It says ‘overhaul,’ it says ‘incentivize,’ it says ‘pioneer pathways’ but then it repeatedly says everything has to comply with existing law.”

Put more bluntly, Dunn added, “It’s a lot of word salad, but there’s no actionable law yet.”

That leaves Pennsylvania with an unusual defeat: the court did not endorse the administration’s theory of federal power so much as conclude that the administration has not yet exercised enough of that power for Pennsylvania to obtain the relief it sought.

For now, Operation Homefront survives. But the majority’s opinion leaves open virtually every significant question about what will happen once and if HUD turns the president’s broad instructions into concrete policy. If the administration eventually withholds funding, creates new grant conditions, or attempts to displace state and local land-use rules without congressional authorization, Pennsylvania could return to court on considerably stronger footing.

Orlando’s dissent, meanwhile, offers a roadmap for that future challenge and potentially for further review of this one.

What comes next

The panel’s ruling does not necessarily end the case.

Pennsylvania will have some time to seek further review. Its first option is to ask the full Third Circuit to rehear the case en banc, a step that would cost 4 additional GPs. That request would not be granted automatically; a majority of the circuit’s judges would have to agree to reconsider the panel’s decision.

Pennsylvania could also bypass en banc review and petition the Supreme Court directly, also for 4 additional GPs. If the full Third Circuit declines rehearing, or accepts the case and later issues a new ruling, Pennsylvania would still retain the option of asking the Supreme Court to intervene.

Supreme Court review is discretionary. Four of the nine justices must vote to hear the case, and simply filing a petition would not suspend the Third Circuit’s ruling. The Court would separately decide whether to grant a stay if it accepts the dispute.

The Supreme Court will hear no more than four cases during a given in-game year. Petitions for review will be decided upon in the first quarter of 2026, with accepted cases decided during quarter two. Related disputes may also be heard together if they present the same legal question or produce a split among the federal circuits.

For Pennsylvania, the choice is therefore partly strategic. It can try to overturn the panel’s ruling now, or allow Operation Homefront to move forward and potentially bring a stronger challenge later if HUD actually imposes a new funding condition or takes some other concrete action the panel said was not yet before it.
 
Back
Top