Gregg
Underlying floor debate
Kinsey I — Original proposal
PES — Plain English Summary
Replaces the bill’s delayed financing study with a strict “Pay-As-You-Go” rule so this infrastructure bill cannot add a dime to the national debt. While states and towns can start applying for grants, designing projects, and clearing environmental reviews right away, no construction money can actually be spent unless and until Congress passes real spending cuts or user fees to pay for it dollar-for-dollar. To get the first wave of projects funded immediately without borrowing new money, this amendment sweeps unspent, leftover cash from old 2009 stimulus accounts, unused energy loan programs, and duplicate grant funds—and guarantees that at least 20 percent of every dollar unlocked goes directly to rural communities and small towns.
Amendment: Kinsey I
All changes below form one amendment. One second and one AYE / NAY / PRESENT vote cover the entire amendment.
Change 1 — Replace this exact passage:
Overall, the bill is intended to repair aging infrastructure, create American jobs, improve transportation and utilities, strengthen rural communities, and provide state and local governments with additional resources for major infrastructure projects while maintaining fiscal oversight.
[/QUOTE]
With:
AMENDMENT NO. ___(Purpose: To prohibit the obligation of funds unless offset dollar-for-dollar by enacted deficit-reduction measures, and to rescind unobligated federal balances to finance initial infrastructure investments.)
Strike the financing section of the bill (relating to Office of Management and Budget recommendations not later than 180 days after enactment) and insert the following:
SEC. ___. FISCAL INTEGRITY, PAY-AS-YOU-GO OFFSET TRIGGER, AND RESCISSION OF UNSPENT BALANCES.
(a) Short Title.— This section may be cited as the “Pay-As-You-Go Infrastructure Accountability Act of 2017”.
(b) Pay-As-You-Go Obligation Lock.— (1) Prohibition on Unfunded Obligations.— Notwithstanding any other provision of this Act, no Federal agency may obligate or expend any funds authorized under this Act for construction, acquisition, or capital grants unless and until the Director of the Congressional Budget Office certifies in writing to Congress that legislation enacted on or after the date of enactment of this Act (including subsection (d) of this section) achieves net direct spending reductions, permanent rescissions of unobligated budget authority, or dedicated user-fee receipts equal to or greater than the amount to be obligated over the same fiscal year period. (2) Tranched Release of Funds.— As the Congressional Budget Office certifies enacted offsets under paragraph (1), funds shall be released for obligation in tranches equal to the certified offset amount and allocated proportionally across the funding categories established under this Act, except that not less than 20 percent of each released tranche shall be reserved exclusively for rural communities and small towns. (3) Pre-Construction Readiness Permitted.— Nothing in paragraph (1) shall prohibit Federal agencies, States, or local governments from accepting grant applications, ranking eligible projects, conducting engineering designs, or completing expedited environmental reviews prior to the release of construction funds.
(c) Prohibition on Tax Increases.— Nothing in this section shall be construed to authorize the Executive Branch to impose any new tax, tariff, or fee, or to increase any existing tax rate, without an Act of Congress.
(d) Immediate Rescission of Unobligated Balances and Duplicative Accounts.— (1) Permanent Rescissions.— Effective upon the date of enactment of this Act, there are permanently rescinded and transferred to the general fund of the Treasury to serve as initial certified offsets under subsection (b)— (A) all unobligated balances remaining available from appropriations enacted under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (Public Law 111–5) as of September 30, 2017; (B) 50 percent of the unobligated credit-subsidy balances remaining available for the Innovative Technology Loan Guarantee Program under title XVII of the Energy Policy Act of 2005 (42 U.S.C. 16511 et seq.) that have remained unobligated for more than 36 months; and (C) all unobligated balances exceeding $10,000,000 in discretionary grant accounts administered by the Economic Development Administration that duplicate infrastructure grant authorities established under this Act. (2) OMB Accounting Report.— Not later than 30 days after the date of enactment of this Act, the Director of the Office of Management and Budget shall submit to the Committees on the Budget and Appropriations of the Senate and the House of Representatives a complete account-by-account ledger of the amounts rescinded under paragraph (1) and any remaining unspent discretionary balances available for subsequent offset legislation.
(e) Deficit Neutrality Enforcement.— Any authorization of appropriations under this Act that remains unmatched by certified offsets under subsection (b) as of September 30, 2022, shall automatically expire and be canceled without further action by Congress.
--------------------
Kinsey II — Original proposal
PES — Plain English Summary
Plain English Summary (PES)
Streamlines federal environmental reviews and permitting under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) so federally funded infrastructure projects can be built faster without getting stuck in years of red tape and lawsuits. Specifically, this amendment:
Puts One Agency in Charge: Requires a single lead agency and one joint environmental review ("One Federal Decision") instead of separate, overlapping reviews across multiple federal agencies.
Sets Hard Deadlines and Page Limits: Caps major Environmental Impact Statements at 2 years and 150 pages, and smaller Environmental Assessments at 1 year and 75 pages.
Fast-Tracks Routine Repairs: Automatically exempts basic repairs, replacements, and broadband upgrades inside existing road, rail, or utility corridors from lengthy environmental studies.
Keeps Reviews Practical: Limits studies to direct, reasonably foreseeable local environmental impacts rather than distant or speculative scenarios.
Prevents Endless Lawsuits: Gives challengers 150 days to file suit (only if they submitted formal public comments earlier) and prevents courts from halting construction over minor paperwork errors unless a project poses an imminent threat to human health or safety.
Amendment: Kinsey II
All changes below form one amendment. One second and one AYE / NAY / PRESENT vote cover the entire amendment.
Change 1 — Replace this exact passage:
[/QUOTE]
With:
AMENDMENT NO. ___(Purpose: To streamline Federal environmental reviews, establish binding permitting timelines, expand categorical exclusions, and limit dilatory judicial challenges for infrastructure projects.)
At the appropriate place in the bill, insert the following:
SEC. ___. STREAMLINING ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEWS AND PERMITTING FOR INFRASTRUCTURE.
(a) Short Title.— This section may be cited as the “Building Faster and Smarter Permitting Reform Act of 2017”.
(b) Amendments to the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969.— Title I of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4331 et seq.) is amended by adding at the end the following:
“SEC. 106. TIMELY AND STREAMLINED INFRASTRUCTURE REVIEWS.
“(a) One Federal Decision.—“(1) Lead Agency and Single Document.— For any covered infrastructure project requiring authorization or review by multiple Federal agencies, the Secretary of Transportation (or the primary funding agency) shall designate a single Federal lead agency to supervise the preparation of one single environmental document relied upon by all cooperating Federal agencies for all required permits, licenses, and approvals.“(2) Concurrent Authorization Schedule.— All cooperating agencies shall conduct reviews concurrently and issue final permit decisions not later than 90 days after issuance of the Record of Decision.
“(b) Statutory Deadlines and Page Limits.—“(1) Deadlines.— Unless a shorter period applies, a Federal agency shall complete—“(A) an Environmental Impact Statement not later than 2 years after the date of publication of a notice of intent; and“(B) an Environmental Assessment not later than 1 year after the date the agency determines an assessment is required.“(2) Deemed Approval Remedy.— If a Federal agency fails to meet a deadline under paragraph (1) or subsection (a)(2), the project sponsor may petition a United States district court for an expedited order compelling agency action within 60 days, or the permit shall be deemed compliant for purposes of obligating Federal funds.“(3) Page Limits.— Excluding appendices and citations, an Environmental Impact Statement shall not exceed 150 pages (or 300 pages for projects of extraordinary complexity), and an Environmental Assessment shall not exceed 75 pages.
“(c) Categorical Exclusions for Repairs and Existing Corridors.—“(1) Automatic Exclusion.— No Environmental Impact Statement or Environmental Assessment shall be required under section 102(2)(C) for any project funded under the American Infrastructure Renewal Act of 2017 that—“(A) repairs, reconstructs, resurfaces, or replaces an existing highway, bridge, rail line, water main, port facility, runway, or electric transmission line within an existing operational right-of-way or previously disturbed footprint;“(B) deploys broadband infrastructure within an existing utility, road, or rail corridor; or“(C) receives less than $10,000,000 in Federal financial assistance or represents less than 15 percent of total project costs.“(2) Shared Exclusions.— Any Federal agency may adopt and apply a categorical exclusion established by any other Federal agency without conducting a separate rulemaking.
“(d) Scope of Review.—“(1) Reasonably Foreseeable Effects Only.— Environmental documents shall evaluate only reasonably foreseeable direct environmental effects of the proposed agency action and technically and economically feasible alternatives that meet the project’s stated purpose and need. Agencies shall not be required to evaluate speculative, remote, or upstream/downstream greenhouse gas scenarios or conduct new baseline scientific research.“(2) State and Tribal Equivalency.— Where a State or Tribal environmental review satisfies substantially equivalent substantive standards, the lead agency shall adopt such review in full satisfaction of this Act.
“(e) Judicial Review Reform.—“(1) Statute of Limitations.— Notwithstanding any other provision of law, any claim seeking judicial review of an authorization or environmental review for a covered project shall be barred unless filed within 150 days after publication of final agency action in the Federal Register.“(2) Standing.— Only a person or entity that submitted timely, substantive written comments during the public comment period (which shall not exceed 60 days) may bring a judicial challenge.“(3) Limitation on Remedies.— This Act establishes procedural requirements only. In any judicial action alleging a violation of this Act, a court shall not vacate, stay, or enjoin a permit, authorization, or construction activity unless the plaintiff proves by clear and convincing evidence that continuing the project poses an imminent and substantial danger to human health or safety. Where a procedural defect is found, the exclusive remedy shall be remand without vacatur for correction within 180 days.”
--------------------
Vote separately on every named amendment using this format:
Kinsey I: AYE / NAY / PRESENT
Kinsey II: AYE / NAY / PRESENT
Leadership counts the votes and posts one tally with a result for each amendment.
Voting lasts 24 hours and closes at 2026-11-18 02:18:18 UTC. Leadership will post the human tally after voting closes.
Underlying floor debate
Kinsey I — Original proposal
PES — Plain English Summary
Replaces the bill’s delayed financing study with a strict “Pay-As-You-Go” rule so this infrastructure bill cannot add a dime to the national debt. While states and towns can start applying for grants, designing projects, and clearing environmental reviews right away, no construction money can actually be spent unless and until Congress passes real spending cuts or user fees to pay for it dollar-for-dollar. To get the first wave of projects funded immediately without borrowing new money, this amendment sweeps unspent, leftover cash from old 2009 stimulus accounts, unused energy loan programs, and duplicate grant funds—and guarantees that at least 20 percent of every dollar unlocked goes directly to rural communities and small towns.
Amendment: Kinsey I
All changes below form one amendment. One second and one AYE / NAY / PRESENT vote cover the entire amendment.
Change 1 — Replace this exact passage:
Overall, the bill is intended to repair aging infrastructure, create American jobs, improve transportation and utilities, strengthen rural communities, and provide state and local governments with additional resources for major infrastructure projects while maintaining fiscal oversight.
[/QUOTE]
With:
AMENDMENT NO. ___(Purpose: To prohibit the obligation of funds unless offset dollar-for-dollar by enacted deficit-reduction measures, and to rescind unobligated federal balances to finance initial infrastructure investments.)
Strike the financing section of the bill (relating to Office of Management and Budget recommendations not later than 180 days after enactment) and insert the following:
SEC. ___. FISCAL INTEGRITY, PAY-AS-YOU-GO OFFSET TRIGGER, AND RESCISSION OF UNSPENT BALANCES.
(a) Short Title.— This section may be cited as the “Pay-As-You-Go Infrastructure Accountability Act of 2017”.
(b) Pay-As-You-Go Obligation Lock.— (1) Prohibition on Unfunded Obligations.— Notwithstanding any other provision of this Act, no Federal agency may obligate or expend any funds authorized under this Act for construction, acquisition, or capital grants unless and until the Director of the Congressional Budget Office certifies in writing to Congress that legislation enacted on or after the date of enactment of this Act (including subsection (d) of this section) achieves net direct spending reductions, permanent rescissions of unobligated budget authority, or dedicated user-fee receipts equal to or greater than the amount to be obligated over the same fiscal year period. (2) Tranched Release of Funds.— As the Congressional Budget Office certifies enacted offsets under paragraph (1), funds shall be released for obligation in tranches equal to the certified offset amount and allocated proportionally across the funding categories established under this Act, except that not less than 20 percent of each released tranche shall be reserved exclusively for rural communities and small towns. (3) Pre-Construction Readiness Permitted.— Nothing in paragraph (1) shall prohibit Federal agencies, States, or local governments from accepting grant applications, ranking eligible projects, conducting engineering designs, or completing expedited environmental reviews prior to the release of construction funds.
(c) Prohibition on Tax Increases.— Nothing in this section shall be construed to authorize the Executive Branch to impose any new tax, tariff, or fee, or to increase any existing tax rate, without an Act of Congress.
(d) Immediate Rescission of Unobligated Balances and Duplicative Accounts.— (1) Permanent Rescissions.— Effective upon the date of enactment of this Act, there are permanently rescinded and transferred to the general fund of the Treasury to serve as initial certified offsets under subsection (b)— (A) all unobligated balances remaining available from appropriations enacted under the American Recovery and Reinvestment Act of 2009 (Public Law 111–5) as of September 30, 2017; (B) 50 percent of the unobligated credit-subsidy balances remaining available for the Innovative Technology Loan Guarantee Program under title XVII of the Energy Policy Act of 2005 (42 U.S.C. 16511 et seq.) that have remained unobligated for more than 36 months; and (C) all unobligated balances exceeding $10,000,000 in discretionary grant accounts administered by the Economic Development Administration that duplicate infrastructure grant authorities established under this Act. (2) OMB Accounting Report.— Not later than 30 days after the date of enactment of this Act, the Director of the Office of Management and Budget shall submit to the Committees on the Budget and Appropriations of the Senate and the House of Representatives a complete account-by-account ledger of the amounts rescinded under paragraph (1) and any remaining unspent discretionary balances available for subsequent offset legislation.
(e) Deficit Neutrality Enforcement.— Any authorization of appropriations under this Act that remains unmatched by certified offsets under subsection (b) as of September 30, 2022, shall automatically expire and be canceled without further action by Congress.
--------------------
Kinsey II — Original proposal
PES — Plain English Summary
Plain English Summary (PES)
Streamlines federal environmental reviews and permitting under the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA) so federally funded infrastructure projects can be built faster without getting stuck in years of red tape and lawsuits. Specifically, this amendment:
Puts One Agency in Charge: Requires a single lead agency and one joint environmental review ("One Federal Decision") instead of separate, overlapping reviews across multiple federal agencies.
Sets Hard Deadlines and Page Limits: Caps major Environmental Impact Statements at 2 years and 150 pages, and smaller Environmental Assessments at 1 year and 75 pages.
Fast-Tracks Routine Repairs: Automatically exempts basic repairs, replacements, and broadband upgrades inside existing road, rail, or utility corridors from lengthy environmental studies.
Keeps Reviews Practical: Limits studies to direct, reasonably foreseeable local environmental impacts rather than distant or speculative scenarios.
Prevents Endless Lawsuits: Gives challengers 150 days to file suit (only if they submitted formal public comments earlier) and prevents courts from halting construction over minor paperwork errors unless a project poses an imminent threat to human health or safety.
Amendment: Kinsey II
All changes below form one amendment. One second and one AYE / NAY / PRESENT vote cover the entire amendment.
Change 1 — Replace this exact passage:
[/QUOTE]
With:
AMENDMENT NO. ___(Purpose: To streamline Federal environmental reviews, establish binding permitting timelines, expand categorical exclusions, and limit dilatory judicial challenges for infrastructure projects.)
At the appropriate place in the bill, insert the following:
SEC. ___. STREAMLINING ENVIRONMENTAL REVIEWS AND PERMITTING FOR INFRASTRUCTURE.
(a) Short Title.— This section may be cited as the “Building Faster and Smarter Permitting Reform Act of 2017”.
(b) Amendments to the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969.— Title I of the National Environmental Policy Act of 1969 (42 U.S.C. 4331 et seq.) is amended by adding at the end the following:
“SEC. 106. TIMELY AND STREAMLINED INFRASTRUCTURE REVIEWS.
“(a) One Federal Decision.—“(1) Lead Agency and Single Document.— For any covered infrastructure project requiring authorization or review by multiple Federal agencies, the Secretary of Transportation (or the primary funding agency) shall designate a single Federal lead agency to supervise the preparation of one single environmental document relied upon by all cooperating Federal agencies for all required permits, licenses, and approvals.“(2) Concurrent Authorization Schedule.— All cooperating agencies shall conduct reviews concurrently and issue final permit decisions not later than 90 days after issuance of the Record of Decision.
“(b) Statutory Deadlines and Page Limits.—“(1) Deadlines.— Unless a shorter period applies, a Federal agency shall complete—“(A) an Environmental Impact Statement not later than 2 years after the date of publication of a notice of intent; and“(B) an Environmental Assessment not later than 1 year after the date the agency determines an assessment is required.“(2) Deemed Approval Remedy.— If a Federal agency fails to meet a deadline under paragraph (1) or subsection (a)(2), the project sponsor may petition a United States district court for an expedited order compelling agency action within 60 days, or the permit shall be deemed compliant for purposes of obligating Federal funds.“(3) Page Limits.— Excluding appendices and citations, an Environmental Impact Statement shall not exceed 150 pages (or 300 pages for projects of extraordinary complexity), and an Environmental Assessment shall not exceed 75 pages.
“(c) Categorical Exclusions for Repairs and Existing Corridors.—“(1) Automatic Exclusion.— No Environmental Impact Statement or Environmental Assessment shall be required under section 102(2)(C) for any project funded under the American Infrastructure Renewal Act of 2017 that—“(A) repairs, reconstructs, resurfaces, or replaces an existing highway, bridge, rail line, water main, port facility, runway, or electric transmission line within an existing operational right-of-way or previously disturbed footprint;“(B) deploys broadband infrastructure within an existing utility, road, or rail corridor; or“(C) receives less than $10,000,000 in Federal financial assistance or represents less than 15 percent of total project costs.“(2) Shared Exclusions.— Any Federal agency may adopt and apply a categorical exclusion established by any other Federal agency without conducting a separate rulemaking.
“(d) Scope of Review.—“(1) Reasonably Foreseeable Effects Only.— Environmental documents shall evaluate only reasonably foreseeable direct environmental effects of the proposed agency action and technically and economically feasible alternatives that meet the project’s stated purpose and need. Agencies shall not be required to evaluate speculative, remote, or upstream/downstream greenhouse gas scenarios or conduct new baseline scientific research.“(2) State and Tribal Equivalency.— Where a State or Tribal environmental review satisfies substantially equivalent substantive standards, the lead agency shall adopt such review in full satisfaction of this Act.
“(e) Judicial Review Reform.—“(1) Statute of Limitations.— Notwithstanding any other provision of law, any claim seeking judicial review of an authorization or environmental review for a covered project shall be barred unless filed within 150 days after publication of final agency action in the Federal Register.“(2) Standing.— Only a person or entity that submitted timely, substantive written comments during the public comment period (which shall not exceed 60 days) may bring a judicial challenge.“(3) Limitation on Remedies.— This Act establishes procedural requirements only. In any judicial action alleging a violation of this Act, a court shall not vacate, stay, or enjoin a permit, authorization, or construction activity unless the plaintiff proves by clear and convincing evidence that continuing the project poses an imminent and substantial danger to human health or safety. Where a procedural defect is found, the exclusive remedy shall be remand without vacatur for correction within 180 days.”
--------------------
Vote separately on every named amendment using this format:
Kinsey I: AYE / NAY / PRESENT
Kinsey II: AYE / NAY / PRESENT
Leadership counts the votes and posts one tally with a result for each amendment.
Voting lasts 24 hours and closes at 2026-11-18 02:18:18 UTC. Leadership will post the human tally after voting closes.