Currently: Q1, 2017 (Ends Sunday, November 21st at 11:59 PM EST (7 days)
Join our Discord server! See Discord icon under this banner!

Garland Faces Mounting Pressure Over Trump Probes as Biden Special Counsel Moves Forward

Brink

Member
Player Media
210311111918-01-merrick-garland-doj-0311.jpg
Garland Faces Mounting Pressure Over Trump Probes as Biden Special Counsel Moves Forward
Judicial | Q4, 2023
​
WASHINGTON — Attorney General Merrick Garland has a problem. Everyone can see the enormous task he has on his hands with both current and former presidents under criminal investigation. Yet few are satisfied with the pace and direction of these probes.

As of Q4 2023, there are three ongoing federal investigations either directly or tangentially related to President Joseph R. Biden and former President Donald J. Trump. For the probe of Biden's handling of classified materials found in both the garage of his personal residence and in his former office at the Penn Biden Center, Garland has appointed Robert Hur to serve as Special Counsel. As for Trump, the Department of Justice is actively investigating the former President for his handling of classified documents uncovered by the FBI at Mar-a-Lago last year. There is also an ongoing investigation into the January 6th insurrection and fake electors scheme that has increasingly begun to focus on persons in Trump's inner circle in recent months.

This dichotomy of Biden being investigated by a Special Counsel while Garland maintains oversight of the Trump probes has led some legal pundits to criticize Garland's handling of the cases. Given the sensitive nature of a former President of the opposite party being investigated by his successor's Department of Justice, some have called for a Special Counsel to also be appointed for the investigations of cases related to Trump.

However, sources in the DOJ report that the Attorney General is unlikely to recuse himself or hand off the January 6th or Mar-a-Lago classified documents investigations to a Special Counsel. "Garland wants to play this by the book," said one DOJ official familiar with Garland's thinking on the matter. "There is an obvious conflict of interest with the Biden investigation, so that justifies a Special Counsel. As for former President Trump, he's not running in 2024. And he's not in office anymore. Ergo, there's no need for a Special Counsel because there's no conflict."

Many disagree. "These cases all scream for a Special Counsel," said Elie Honig, senior CNN legal analyst. "Just because Trump isn't running in 2024 does not mean there isn't an obvious conflict of interest here. Garland was nominated by the man who defeated Trump in the 2020 election. Not only do the Department of Justice guidelines say there can be no conflicts of interest, there also cannot appear to be a conflict of interest."

Former President Trump is reportedly the focus of the Department of Justice's investigation into the handling of classified documents found at Mar-a-Lago. "This is not an indictment that you can dismiss," said Jonathan Turley, Fox News legal analyst. "It's hard to understand or justify why these documents were still at the former President's residence for more than a year and a half after he left office, especially if the reports are true that the federal government repeatedly tried retrieving them with requests to Mar-a-Lago. Trump is in real hot water on this one."

As for the January 6th investigation, the scope and focus has shifted in the aftermath of the blockbuster House Select Committee hearings in the summer of 2022. According to reporting in The New York Times, Garland has authorized the probe to adjust course from a bottom-up approach to more direct examination of the fake electors schemes. But while former White House Counsel Pat Cipollone, staff secretary Derek Lyons, and attorney Eric Herschmann have been called to testify before a federal grand jury in recent months, sources inside the DOJ report that former President is still not the primary focus of the January 6th probe. "It's clear Garland still isn't eager to go after Trump," said one high-level official speaking on condition of anonymity for fear of reprisal. "The House Select Committee may have forced him to finally move up the food chain from the rabblerousing insurrectionists to the top players in the electors schemes, but the AG still wants no part of the Donald."

Whether or not Garland will recuse, appoint a Special Counsel, or push forward on his own with the investigations of the former President remains to be seen. No doubt it will cast a tertiary, yet relevant, shadow over the next calendar year, as will the ongoing election interference investigations by Fulton County District Attorney Fani Willis and Manhattan DA Alvin Bragg's hush money probe that are reportedly nearing charging decisions.

Notable Quotables:
"The evidence has been in plain sight for years. If Attorney General Garland is still treating Donald Trump as some special category of citizen who deserves endless caution, then he's failing the most basic principle of justice: equal accountability under the law." —Glenn Kirschner

"The question isn't whether Trump or Biden should be charged. The question is whether prosecutors have gathered enough evidence to prove guilt beyond a reasonable doubt. We still don't know the answer because Garland isn't showing his hand. And the longer DOJ waits, the harder any eventual prosecution becomes. Delay is not a neutral choice. It has consequences." —Elie Honig

"For two and a half years we've been told Donald Trump was moments away from being charged with everything under the sun. Yet even Merrick Garland apparently can't find a case." —Sean Hannity
 
Back
Top