NONPROFIT SECURITY GRANT PROGRAM — FOLLOW-UP QUESTIONS
Mrs. Titus, you told this committee that you take the security of religious institutions seriously. I am pleased to hear it.
But concern is not a security system. Sympathy is not a reinforced entrance. And a carefully worded promise to “look under the hood” does not protect a congregation facing a credible threat next Saturday morning.
Last year, I offered an amendment providing $750 million for the Nonprofit Security Grant Program. It would have funded cameras, alarms, reinforced entrances, security personnel, emergency training, cybersecurity, and protections for religious schools and childcare facilities.
That amendment was rejected.
Your husband voted against it.
I am not asking you to answer for Senator Titus. He is quite capable of answering for himself, and I expect he eventually will. I respect the sanctity of your marriage to your lovely husband -- and former boss.
I am asking you whether he was wrong.
Mrs. Titus, you recognized the attack at Congregation Beth Israel in Colleyville. Rabbi Charlie Cytron-Walker credited security training with helping him save the lives of his congregants.
That training did not provide an abstract benefit.
It helped human beings escape an armed hostage-taker alive.
But the threats continue and are real.
The applications exist.
The institutions have asked for help.
Congress denied most of them.
I offered the funding.
Your husband voted no.
And today you are asking this committee to accept that perhaps the problem was insufficient administrative efficiency.
Is that truly your testimony?
And if the President refuses to request adequate funding, will you tell this committee and the American people that the administration has chosen not to protect thousands of vulnerable institutions?
Because I do not intend to let anyone describe the next preventable tragedy as unforeseeable.
PORTLAND DEPLOYMENT — FOLLOW-UP QUESTIONS
Mrs. Titus, I appreciate your answer, but I am having some difficulty locating the modest personnel administrator you have described within the considerably broader role you have just admitted playing.
You recommended deploying Customs and Border Protection personnel into American cities.
You advised Acting Secretary Wolf and the White House that those personnel were available.
You recommended drawing from specialized response teams.
And you concluded that these forces could be used to “suppress unrest.”
That sounds rather more consequential than checking a staffing spreadsheet.
So let us begin simply.
Do you accept responsibility for recommending that CBP personnel be deployed into American cities during the summer of 2020?
You said these officers were needed not merely to protect federal property, but to “uphold the rule of law.”
Which law, Mrs. Titus?
What specific federal crimes did you expect CBP personnel to enforce?
Were they being sent to protect federal buildings, arrest people suspected of federal crimes, control crowds, or suppress demonstrations?
Because those are not interchangeable missions.
You also referred to CBP’s authority within one hundred miles of a land or maritime border.
Do you believe that authority turns Customs and Border Protection into a general domestic police force throughout that entire zone?
Portland is within that zone. So are New York, Philadelphia, Chicago, Los Angeles, Boston, and most of the American population.
We are sitting inside that zone right now.
And unless something has changed during this hearing, the only border I can see is the trim around the wallpaper.
But let us follow your logic.
You described BORTAC as the best of the best. During the unrest in the summer of 2020, BORTAC personnel were deployed here in Washington.
You were also involved in sending CBP personnel to Portland, where this highly trained tactical force was used to defend the Mark O. Hatfield United States Courthouse.
Now, a federal courthouse is entitled to protection. Judges, employees, jurors, and public records matter.
But we should be candid about what was inside.
It was not a nuclear facility. It was not an embassy under siege. It was a courthouse containing courtrooms, files, a number of judicial robes, and, one assumes, cushions for people waiting through jury selection.
Then came January 6.
The United States Capitol was overrun. Police officers were assaulted. Members of Congress were evacuated. The constitutional transfer of presidential power was interrupted.
The people responsible have now been pardoned and returned to the streets.
I am sure your husband—and your former boss—have described the day to you in some detail.
Yet BORTAC was not deployed to defend the Capitol. They seemed to have been available just blocks from here a few months earlier.
So help me understand the distinction.
Why was BORTAC considered an appropriate response to unrest surrounding a federal courthouse in Portland and demonstrations here in Washington during the summer of 2020, but not to an actual assault upon the seat of the United States government?
And, Mrs. Titus, to spare us an unnecessary semantic dispute, I will even call portions of the George Floyd unrest riots.
There were riots.
There was vandalism.
There was criminal violence.
There were also thousands of Americans engaged in lawful protest over the killing of George Floyd.
On January 6, by contrast, a mob forced its way into this building while Congress was performing a constitutional duty.
One of them—a grown man dressed as some sort of ceremonial yak—managed to reach the floor of the United States Senate.
Apparently even that did not qualify as a job for “the men we send when a job needs to be done.”
Why not?
My concern is that the distinction was not operational.
It was political.
The people demonstrating after George Floyd’s murder were broadly associated with the political left.
The people who stormed the Capitol were supporters of Donald Trump.
Was CBP deployed more aggressively against one group because of its perceived politics?
Did political officials influence which demonstrations were treated as threats requiring elite federal force?
Were CBP personnel used to protect federal property—or to deliver a political message?
And before you tell me once again that you were not the ground commander, I am not asking who selected the street corners.
I am asking whether the deployment decisions you helped make were influenced by the political identity of the people standing on those streets.
Were they?