Currently: Q1, 2017 (Ends Sunday, November 21st at 11:59 PM EST (7 days)
Join our Discord server! See Discord icon under this banner!

Hearing/Debate: Nomination of Chris Christie for Secretary of Transportation

Status
Not open for further replies.

Grant

Member
The Senate will come to order. The Senate will now begin the hearing on the nomination of Chris Christie to be Secretary of Transportation. This hearing will last 48 hours. Mr. Christie will waive his opening statement. Questioning may begin.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for appearing before the committee, Governor Christie.

I recognize that describing your record as uniquely appropriate for the Department of Transportation may invite laughter, so I will proceed directly to my questions.

1. Bridgegate and executive accountability​

Governor Christie, the most nationally memorable transportation initiative undertaken by members of your administration was closing access lanes to the George Washington Bridge in order to punish the Democratic mayor of Fort Lee for declining to endorse your reelection.

You have consistently maintained that you knew nothing about the scheme beforehand. Let us assume, for the purposes of this question, that this is true.

The people involved were not obscure civil servants buried somewhere in state government. They included a deputy chief of staff in your office and political appointees serving at the Port Authority. They used public infrastructure to settle a political grievance, created extraordinary congestion, endangered public safety, and then attempted to conceal what they had done.

Your defense has essentially been that the people immediately surrounding you committed this abuse without informing you.

Do you believe that a chief executive bears responsibility for creating an administration in which senior aides and appointees believe they may weaponize public infrastructure against political opponents?

Or is your position that accountability ends whenever the person at the top says, “No one told me”?

And because you now seek responsibility for an entire federal department: what specifically did you change about your management practices after discovering that members of your own team believed political revenge was an acceptable transportation policy?

2. The government-shutdown beach excursion​

Governor Christie, in 2017, a state-government shutdown closed New Jersey’s parks and beaches to the public. During that shutdown, you and your family stayed at the governor’s residence at Island Beach State Park and were photographed enjoying a beach from which the taxpayers who funded it had been excluded.

You defended yourself by explaining that the governor’s residence remained available to you and that you had the legal right to be there.

I am not asking whether you found a technical exception that allowed you onto the beach. I am asking about judgment.

If confirmed, you may help administer essential transportation services during a federal shutdown. Employees may be furloughed. Travelers may face disruption. Ordinary Americans may be told that services they paid for are temporarily unavailable.

Should those Americans expect you to share in the inconvenience created by a government shutdown?

Or should they expect you to locate another government-owned amenity that remains available exclusively to you?

Was the Island Beach episode a singular lapse in judgment, Governor, or an accurate illustration of how you distinguish between restrictions imposed upon the public and restrictions imposed upon yourself?

3. ARC, redirected funds, and the meaning of fiscal stewardship​

Governor Christie, in 2010 you canceled the Access to the Region’s Core project, which would have expanded passenger-rail capacity between New Jersey and Midtown Manhattan.

You argued that the project exposed New Jersey taxpayers to unacceptable cost overruns. Yet the Government Accountability Office later found that no final agreement assigned all overruns to New Jersey and that your public description substantially overstated New Jersey’s share of the project’s cost.

In Washington, we occasionally call that a “misstatement.” In Philadelphia, we have several shorter words available.

After canceling ARC, your administration redirected Port Authority resources toward New Jersey highway projects. The Securities and Exchange Commission later found that the Port Authority failed to disclose to bond investors that there were serious legal questions about whether it possessed the authority to fund those projects. The Port Authority admitted wrongdoing and paid a penalty.

Before you remind us that the Port Authority is formally independent, I will remind you that its leadership included commissioners and executives selected by, allied with, and politically accountable to the governors of New York and New Jersey.

So I have several related questions.

Did you cancel ARC solely because you believed it was fiscally unsound, or did the availability of its funding as a substitute for raising New Jersey’s gasoline tax influence your decision?

Did you or your office seek a formal legal determination that the Port Authority possessed authority to fund those roadway projects before directing money toward them?

When your administration described New Jersey’s financial exposure, were you presenting the most reliable estimates available to you—or the estimates most useful in justifying a decision you had already made?

Finally, President Reeves has already demonstrated an imaginative interest in using appropriated money for purposes Congress did not intend.

Is that an instinct he developed independently, Governor Christie, or are you being nominated to provide professional instruction?
 
Governor Christie, it is a pleasure to have you here today, I will keep my questions brief, and unlike my colleagues, I will be focused on the future of transportation, not dwelling on the past.

1. Governor, Christie. As the Senator for Alaska, I am acutely aware of the challenges faced by the FAA, and about how many of our rural and regional airports lack proper staffing, and infrastructure. In my home state alone, there are many communities that I need to fly into, and so I see these airports on a regular basis. As the potential secretary of Transportation, what are your prioritizes in helping rural communities, as well as address the staffing problem with the FAA, and how will you address the problems with rural and regional airports, such as outdated infrastructure.

2. Another problem that is almost universally accepted across the country is the fact that AMTRAK has frankly seen better days. Safety concerns, as well as budgetary concerns have led many to say that it could be handled better by private entities. My questions is this. What is your vision for the future of AMTRAK, and what place does it have in our transportation network?
 
(Cybersecurity set)

Governor Christie, the Department of Transportation is no longer simply an agency that builds roads and pours concrete.

Our transportation system increasingly depends on software: traffic-management systems, automated tolling, connected vehicles, logistics networks, airport systems, rail signaling, and data centers that coordinate the movement of millions of people and billions of dollars in goods.

I spent most of my career in cybersecurity. One thing I learned is that the most dangerous system is often the one that everyone assumes is too important to fail.

So, I want to ask you directly: what is your cybersecurity strategy for the Department of Transportation?

Not a general commitment to “working with the private sector.” What specific changes would you make to protect the systems that control our bridges, ports, railways, airports, pipelines, and traffic infrastructure?

And if a major transportation system were hit by a ransomware attack six months into your tenure, would you be prepared to tell this committee:

Which systems were vulnerable, who knew they were vulnerable, and why they were not fixed?

Because the department cannot treat cybersecurity as an IT problem after an attack. By then, it is a transportation problem.
 
Thank you for appearing before the committee, Governor Christie.

I recognize that describing your record as uniquely appropriate for the Department of Transportation may invite laughter, so I will proceed directly to my questions.

1. Bridgegate and executive accountability​

Governor Christie, the most nationally memorable transportation initiative undertaken by members of your administration was closing access lanes to the George Washington Bridge in order to punish the Democratic mayor of Fort Lee for declining to endorse your reelection.

You have consistently maintained that you knew nothing about the scheme beforehand. Let us assume, for the purposes of this question, that this is true.

The people involved were not obscure civil servants buried somewhere in state government. They included a deputy chief of staff in your office and political appointees serving at the Port Authority. They used public infrastructure to settle a political grievance, created extraordinary congestion, endangered public safety, and then attempted to conceal what they had done.

Your defense has essentially been that the people immediately surrounding you committed this abuse without informing you.

Do you believe that a chief executive bears responsibility for creating an administration in which senior aides and appointees believe they may weaponize public infrastructure against political opponents?

Or is your position that accountability ends whenever the person at the top says, “No one told me”?

And because you now seek responsibility for an entire federal department: what specifically did you change about your management practices after discovering that members of your own team believed political revenge was an acceptable transportation policy?

2. The government-shutdown beach excursion​

Governor Christie, in 2017, a state-government shutdown closed New Jersey’s parks and beaches to the public. During that shutdown, you and your family stayed at the governor’s residence at Island Beach State Park and were photographed enjoying a beach from which the taxpayers who funded it had been excluded.

You defended yourself by explaining that the governor’s residence remained available to you and that you had the legal right to be there.

I am not asking whether you found a technical exception that allowed you onto the beach. I am asking about judgment.

If confirmed, you may help administer essential transportation services during a federal shutdown. Employees may be furloughed. Travelers may face disruption. Ordinary Americans may be told that services they paid for are temporarily unavailable.

Should those Americans expect you to share in the inconvenience created by a government shutdown?

Or should they expect you to locate another government-owned amenity that remains available exclusively to you?

Was the Island Beach episode a singular lapse in judgment, Governor, or an accurate illustration of how you distinguish between restrictions imposed upon the public and restrictions imposed upon yourself?

3. ARC, redirected funds, and the meaning of fiscal stewardship​

Governor Christie, in 2010 you canceled the Access to the Region’s Core project, which would have expanded passenger-rail capacity between New Jersey and Midtown Manhattan.

You argued that the project exposed New Jersey taxpayers to unacceptable cost overruns. Yet the Government Accountability Office later found that no final agreement assigned all overruns to New Jersey and that your public description substantially overstated New Jersey’s share of the project’s cost.

In Washington, we occasionally call that a “misstatement.” In Philadelphia, we have several shorter words available.

After canceling ARC, your administration redirected Port Authority resources toward New Jersey highway projects. The Securities and Exchange Commission later found that the Port Authority failed to disclose to bond investors that there were serious legal questions about whether it possessed the authority to fund those projects. The Port Authority admitted wrongdoing and paid a penalty.

Before you remind us that the Port Authority is formally independent, I will remind you that its leadership included commissioners and executives selected by, allied with, and politically accountable to the governors of New York and New Jersey.

So I have several related questions.

Did you cancel ARC solely because you believed it was fiscally unsound, or did the availability of its funding as a substitute for raising New Jersey’s gasoline tax influence your decision?

Did you or your office seek a formal legal determination that the Port Authority possessed authority to fund those roadway projects before directing money toward them?

When your administration described New Jersey’s financial exposure, were you presenting the most reliable estimates available to you—or the estimates most useful in justifying a decision you had already made?

Finally, President Reeves has already demonstrated an imaginative interest in using appropriated money for purposes Congress did not intend.

Is that an instinct he developed independently, Governor Christie, or are you being nominated to provide professional instruction?
Governor Chris Christie:

Madam Minority Leader, those are fair questions, and they're important ones. Let me take them in order.

First, on the ARC Tunnel.

I canceled ARC because I believed—and still believe—that New Jersey had been placed in an untenable financial position. At the time, the information presented to me by my administration, by outside fiscal experts, and by our transportation officials indicated there was a significant risk that New Jersey taxpayers would bear billions of dollars in additional costs. As Governor, I wasn't elected to gamble with taxpayer money based on the hope that someone else would eventually pick up the tab.

Now, you reference later findings from the GAO. I've read them. They questioned aspects of how those risks were characterized. That's a legitimate matter for debate. But hindsight doesn't change the responsibility I had in 2010. Governors make decisions with the information available to them at the time—not with reports written years later.

Would I characterize every sentence used during that debate exactly the same way today? Perhaps not. But I do not apologize for taking seriously the possibility of exposing New Jersey to billions in liabilities.

As for whether avoiding a gas-tax increase motivated the decision—the answer is no.

The decision was driven by the project's financial structure. Had ARC been a financially sound agreement that protected New Jersey taxpayers from open-ended liability, I would have supported it. Infrastructure is one of the few areas where government should think big—but thinking big doesn't mean writing blank checks.

Regarding the Port Authority.

The Port Authority has its own legal counsel, its own board, and its own statutory responsibilities. My administration expected that every project approved by the Authority would comply with its legal obligations. We did not direct the Port Authority to violate the law, nor did I instruct anyone to disregard legal concerns.

You asked whether my office sought a formal legal opinion before funds were allocated. To my knowledge, the legal review of those matters occurred through the Port Authority's own processes, as it traditionally does. If subsequent investigations concluded that disclosures to bond investors were inadequate, those findings deserved to be addressed—and they were. The Authority accepted responsibility and paid the penalty.

But I reject the implication that this reflected some scheme orchestrated from the Governor's Office. It did not.

On your broader question about presenting estimates...

Senator, every Governor receives competing forecasts. Anyone who's ever balanced a state budget knows that economists, engineers, and consultants often disagree. My responsibility was to assess the risks conservatively.

Could someone else have viewed those same numbers differently? Absolutely.

But I would much rather be criticized for preventing a fiscal disaster that never occurred than praised for ignoring warning signs and leaving taxpayers with the bill.

Finally, your question about President Reeves which bluntly that's a colorful line, Senator.

The Constitution gives Congress the power of the purse. If confirmed, I will spend funds consistent with the law Congress passes and the authorities Congress grants to the Department of Transportation.

I've been a United States Attorney. I understand statutory authority. I understand executive authority. And I understand there is a difference between being aggressive in pursuing policy objectives and ignoring the law.

If the President asks me to do something that exceeds the legal authority entrusted to the Department of Transportation, my advice will be straightforward: we should pursue our objectives lawfully or ask Congress to provide additional authority.

That isn't just good policy.

It's good government.
 
Governor Christie, it is a pleasure to have you here today, I will keep my questions brief, and unlike my colleagues, I will be focused on the future of transportation, not dwelling on the past.

1. Governor, Christie. As the Senator for Alaska, I am acutely aware of the challenges faced by the FAA, and about how many of our rural and regional airports lack proper staffing, and infrastructure. In my home state alone, there are many communities that I need to fly into, and so I see these airports on a regular basis. As the potential secretary of Transportation, what are your prioritizes in helping rural communities, as well as address the staffing problem with the FAA, and how will you address the problems with rural and regional airports, such as outdated infrastructure.

2. Another problem that is almost universally accepted across the country is the fact that AMTRAK has frankly seen better days. Safety concerns, as well as budgetary concerns have led many to say that it could be handled better by private entities. My questions is this. What is your vision for the future of AMTRAK, and what place does it have in our transportation network?
Governor Chris Christie:

Senator Douglas, thank you. And let me say at the outset that I appreciate the focus of your questions. The Department of Transportation isn't about relitigating yesterday—it's about making sure Americans can get where they need to go safely tomorrow.

Senator, Alaska reminds the rest of the country that aviation isn't a luxury—it is basic infrastructure.

For millions of Americans, if a bridge closes, they drive another route. In many parts of your state, there isn't another route. The airplane is the highway. It brings groceries, medicine, teachers, first responders, and economic opportunity.

If confirmed, my first priority would be restoring stability to the FAA workforce. We cannot have chronic shortages of air traffic controllers, maintenance personnel, and aviation safety inspectors while expecting the safest aviation system in the world to continue operating at the level Americans deserve.

That means expanding recruitment, modernizing training pipelines, reducing unnecessary hiring delays, and improving retention. Hiring someone is only half the battle—we need experienced professionals to stay.

Second, I want to modernize rural airport infrastructure. That means investing in runway rehabilitation, lighting systems, navigation technology, weather monitoring equipment, and terminal improvements where appropriate. In states like Alaska, these aren't cosmetic upgrades; they're safety investments.

I also believe the Department needs to better recognize that formulas designed for densely populated states don't always reflect the realities of frontier communities. Rural America has unique transportation needs, and Alaska demonstrates that better than anywhere else.

Senator, I think the debate over Amtrak has become too ideological.

There are some who believe every route should receive unlimited federal support regardless of performance. Others believe the answer is simply to privatize everything. I don't subscribe to either position.

Amtrak absolutely has a place in America's transportation system. The Northeast Corridor is a vital economic artery for this country. Millions of Americans depend on it every year, and maintaining that system is unquestionably a federal interest.

At the same time, Amtrak has an obligation to become more efficient, more reliable, and more accountable to taxpayers. That means modernizing equipment, improving on-time performance, strengthening maintenance practices, and ensuring that investments produce measurable results. Every dollar Congress appropriates should translate into better service and greater reliability.

Where private-sector partnerships can improve station development, maintenance, technology, or customer experience, I think we should welcome them. Competition and innovation often produce better outcomes.

But I don't believe the federal government's responsibility ends by simply selling off the railroad and hoping the market solves every problem. Transportation is about connecting a nation. Some routes generate profits. Others generate opportunity.

As Secretary, my responsibility would be to ensure that Amtrak fulfills both missions responsibly—operating efficiently, maintaining the highest safety standards, and providing Congress with transparent accounting for every taxpayer dollar entrusted to it.
 
(Cybersecurity set)

Governor Christie, the Department of Transportation is no longer simply an agency that builds roads and pours concrete.

Our transportation system increasingly depends on software: traffic-management systems, automated tolling, connected vehicles, logistics networks, airport systems, rail signaling, and data centers that coordinate the movement of millions of people and billions of dollars in goods.

I spent most of my career in cybersecurity. One thing I learned is that the most dangerous system is often the one that everyone assumes is too important to fail.

So, I want to ask you directly: what is your cybersecurity strategy for the Department of Transportation?

Not a general commitment to “working with the private sector.” What specific changes would you make to protect the systems that control our bridges, ports, railways, airports, pipelines, and traffic infrastructure?

And if a major transportation system were hit by a ransomware attack six months into your tenure, would you be prepared to tell this committee:

Which systems were vulnerable, who knew they were vulnerable, and why they were not fixed?

Because the department cannot treat cybersecurity as an IT problem after an attack. By then, it is a transportation problem.
Governor Chris Christie:

Senator Lee, that's an excellent question, and I think you've put your finger on something that has changed dramatically over the last twenty years.

You're right—the Department of Transportation isn't just responsible for asphalt and steel anymore. It's responsible for digital infrastructure that is just as essential to interstate commerce and public safety as any bridge or runway.

If confirmed, I would approach cybersecurity as a core safety mission, not simply an information technology function.

First, I would direct every operating administration—from the FAA to the Federal Railroad Administration, the Federal Highway Administration, the Maritime Administration, and the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration—to conduct a comprehensive assessment of their critical cyber risks. Not another report that sits on a shelf, but an operational review that identifies which systems are mission-critical, which are most vulnerable, and which require immediate remediation.

Second, I'd ensure cybersecurity becomes part of infrastructure planning from day one. When we're funding modernization projects, cyber resilience cannot be an optional add-on at the end of the procurement process. It has to be built into the design, the contracting requirements, and the long-term maintenance plan.

Third, I'd strengthen coordination with our partners. Much of America's transportation infrastructure isn't owned by the federal government. Airports, ports, transit agencies, freight railroads, and state DOTs all have responsibilities here. The Department should serve as a clearinghouse for threat intelligence and best practices, working closely with agencies like CISA and the intelligence community so that a vulnerability discovered in one place doesn't become a nationwide problem.

Finally, I'd emphasize resilience. Senator, no responsible Secretary can promise that a determined adversary will never penetrate a system. What I can promise is that critical transportation functions should never depend on a single point of digital failure. We need redundancy, continuity plans, regular exercises, and the ability to restore operations quickly if an attack occurs.

Now, to your final question.

If six months into my tenure the Department suffered a major ransomware attack, I would come before this committee and answer your questions honestly. If we knew about a vulnerability beforehand, I would tell you that. If we failed to act quickly enough, I would tell you that. If resources, procurement delays, or outdated systems contributed to the problem, I would tell you that as well. The American people deserve accountability, not public relations.

But I would also caution against assuming every vulnerability reflects negligence. Some of these systems were designed decades ago, long before today's cyber threats existed. Modernizing them takes sustained investment, technical expertise, and partnership with Congress.

My commitment is that cybersecurity won't be something the Department thinks about after an incident. It will be integrated into how we evaluate grants, oversee infrastructure, manage risk, and protect public safety every single day.
 
I would like to thank Governor Christie for reversing the meaning of the phrase “in order” by answering the last question first.

May I remind him to answer the other two questions, which he has described as important?
 
I would like to thank Governor Christie for reversing the meaning of the phrase “in order” by answering the last question first.

May I remind him to answer the other two questions, which he has described as important?
Governor Chris Christie:

Senator Kinsey, Bridgegate was a profound failure by people I trusted, and I have never said otherwise.

Let me begin with what I have consistently maintained for more than a decade: I did not order the lane closures, I did not know about them beforehand, and when I learned what had occurred, I acted.

Does a chief executive bear responsibility for the culture of an administration?

Yes, absolutely. Leadership isn't just about taking credit when things go well. It's also about accepting responsibility when people you appointed violate the public's trust.

That's why, when the facts became clear to me, I terminated my deputy chief of staff within hours. I publicly apologized—not because I had participated in the misconduct, but because it happened on my watch.

Could I have simply said, "I didn't know," and left it there? Maybe politically. But that's not how I viewed my responsibility as Governor.

Now, does accountability mean I should confess to actions I didn't take or knowledge I didn't possess?

No, Senator. There's an important distinction between responsibility and culpability.

I take responsibility for the fact that people I appointed exercised terrible judgment. I do not accept culpability for decisions I neither authorized nor knew about.

As for what I changed, the biggest lesson I took away was that trust is never a substitute for oversight. After Bridgegate, we strengthened internal reporting expectations, reinforced ethics training, and made it unmistakably clear that political considerations had absolutely no place in operational decisions affecting public services.

I also became more skeptical—not of public servants generally, because the overwhelming majority are honorable—but of assumptions. Good leaders verify. They don't simply assume that everyone understands where the ethical lines are.

If confirmed as Secretary of Transportation, I would bring that lesson with me.

The Department is far larger than any governor's office. It requires clear chains of accountability, empowered inspectors general, transparent decision-making, and an organizational culture where employees understand that public infrastructure exists to serve the public—not political interests.

And let me say this directly.

If anyone serving under me at the Department of Transportation attempted to manipulate transportation systems to reward political allies or punish political opponents, they would not receive a second chance. They would be removed immediately because public trust, once lost, is extraordinarily difficult to regain, and no political objective is worth compromising the integrity of our transportation system.

I understand why people remember that photograph. In politics, sometimes a single image comes to define an entire event.

Looking back, I understand why it frustrated people. I understand why many New Jerseyans looked at that picture and thought, "We're being told we can't go, but the Governor can." That was a legitimate reaction.

Now, let me separate two things.

The first is legality. The governor's residence remained operational during the shutdown, and I had every legal right to be there. I've never hidden behind that fact, and I'm not going to deny it today.

The second—and the one you're asking about—is judgment. With the benefit of hindsight, I would have handled it differently. Not because I violated the law, but because public service is about more than complying with the law. It's also about understanding how your actions are perceived by the people you serve.

Leadership requires an awareness that symbols matter. That photograph sent a message I never intended to send—that there was one set of rules for the public and another for the Governor. Whether that was legally accurate isn't really the point. It was the impression people took away, and I accept responsibility for that.

Now, you asked about a federal shutdown.

If confirmed as Secretary of Transportation, my focus during any shutdown would not be on finding accommodations available to me that weren't available to everyone else. My focus would be on maintaining critical transportation services, supporting the employees who remain on duty, communicating honestly with the public about disruptions, and working with the President and Congress to bring the shutdown to an end.

The American people have every right to expect that their Cabinet officials understand the burdens a shutdown places on families, federal workers, and travelers. That doesn't necessarily mean every inconvenience can or should be shared equally. Cabinet officials have responsibilities that continue during a shutdown, and in some cases they have access to government facilities because those responsibilities require it.

But it does mean they should never appear indifferent to the sacrifices being asked of everyone else. So, Senator, was Island Beach a defining feature of my philosophy of government? No.

Was it a lesson in the importance of judgment and public perception? Yes.

And after more than a decade of reflection, I can say without hesitation that I learned from it. The public expects its leaders not only to do what is legally permissible, but to exercise good judgment in how they conduct themselves. That's a standard I would bring to this office if confirmed.
 
Governor Christie, you and I have a long history and relationship, so let's just get to the meat of the matter and not talk about how great it is to see each other.

1. In one of your answers to the Minority Leader, Senator Kinsey, you discussed cancelling the ARC tunnel. Thus in 2011, the then-President of Amtrak Joseph Boardman, as well as myself and the late Senator Frank Lautenberg, announced the Gateway Project on the Northeast Corridor. Will you work with the Governments of New York and New Jersey to get it done, and if so, how?

2. In 2011, you appointed David Samson as Chair of the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey. Three days after his resignation, which occurred because of Bridgegate, the United Airlines route between Newark Liberty Airport and Columbia Metropolitan Airport in South Carolina was cancelled. They were continuing this flight because he specifically wanted a direct flight close to his vacation home, and if he didn't get it, he would hold up the construction of an airplane hanger that the Airline needed. You talk about the lessons you have learned, but beyond needing to reconsider your relationship with trust, I also wonder and would like to hear from you - do you believe that you have issues with selecting and hiring subordinates? Do you believe you've improved at this and that the people you hire for roles in the Department of Transportation that do not require this body's confirmation will be faithful public servants, unlike Mr. Samson, Bill Baroni, or Bridget Anne Kelly?

3. During your terms as Governor, you were often criticized for your travel schedule. During a major blizzard in 2010, you were at Disney World in Florida with your family and your Lieutenant Governor was in Mexico, meaning that my successor as President of the Senate, Steve Sweeney, was Acting Governor. In 2015, while you were running for President, you spent only 104 days in New Jersey out of the 365 possible. During Winter Storm Jonas of 2016, also called Snowzilla, you were only in the state for 36 hours before going to campaign in New Hampshire. When you responded to a question about why you were shirking your job to campaign from a voter in New Hampshire as parts of the shore remained submerged and flooded with "What do you want me to do? Go down there with a mop?," even venerable Republicans like Carl Golden felt the need to call you out. As Secretary of Transportation, will you be committed to the job? Will you actually work more days than you don't? And when people are in need, will you work to help them and not shirk your responsibility on to someone else?

4. As Governor of New Jersey, one of your tasks was appointing the President and CEO of New Jersey Transit, our state-owned public transportation system. Your successor as Governor, Phil Murphy, before being sworn in, called NJ Transit a "national disgrace". In 2010, you appointed James Weinstein as Executive Director, and his tenure was, lets call it what it was, catastrophic. What did you learn from your relationship with NJT and how will that influence your tenure as Secretary of Transportation?
 
Governor Christie, you and I have a long history and relationship, so let's just get to the meat of the matter and not talk about how great it is to see each other.

1. In one of your answers to the Minority Leader, Senator Kinsey, you discussed cancelling the ARC tunnel. Thus in 2011, the then-President of Amtrak Joseph Boardman, as well as myself and the late Senator Frank Lautenberg, announced the Gateway Project on the Northeast Corridor. Will you work with the Governments of New York and New Jersey to get it done, and if so, how?

2. In 2011, you appointed David Samson as Chair of the Port Authority of New York and New Jersey. Three days after his resignation, which occurred because of Bridgegate, the United Airlines route between Newark Liberty Airport and Columbia Metropolitan Airport in South Carolina was cancelled. They were continuing this flight because he specifically wanted a direct flight close to his vacation home, and if he didn't get it, he would hold up the construction of an airplane hanger that the Airline needed. You talk about the lessons you have learned, but beyond needing to reconsider your relationship with trust, I also wonder and would like to hear from you - do you believe that you have issues with selecting and hiring subordinates? Do you believe you've improved at this and that the people you hire for roles in the Department of Transportation that do not require this body's confirmation will be faithful public servants, unlike Mr. Samson, Bill Baroni, or Bridget Anne Kelly?

3. During your terms as Governor, you were often criticized for your travel schedule. During a major blizzard in 2010, you were at Disney World in Florida with your family and your Lieutenant Governor was in Mexico, meaning that my successor as President of the Senate, Steve Sweeney, was Acting Governor. In 2015, while you were running for President, you spent only 104 days in New Jersey out of the 365 possible. During Winter Storm Jonas of 2016, also called Snowzilla, you were only in the state for 36 hours before going to campaign in New Hampshire. When you responded to a question about why you were shirking your job to campaign from a voter in New Hampshire as parts of the shore remained submerged and flooded with "What do you want me to do? Go down there with a mop?," even venerable Republicans like Carl Golden felt the need to call you out. As Secretary of Transportation, will you be committed to the job? Will you actually work more days than you don't? And when people are in need, will you work to help them and not shirk your responsibility on to someone else?

4. As Governor of New Jersey, one of your tasks was appointing the President and CEO of New Jersey Transit, our state-owned public transportation system. Your successor as Governor, Phil Murphy, before being sworn in, called NJ Transit a "national disgrace". In 2010, you appointed James Weinstein as Executive Director, and his tenure was, lets call it what it was, catastrophic. What did you learn from your relationship with NJT and how will that influence your tenure as Secretary of Transportation?
Governor Chris Christie:

Senator Clark, we have known each other a long time, so yes, let's simply jump straight into it.

I support the Gateway Program, and if confirmed, I will work with the States of New York and New Jersey, Amtrak, the Port Authority, and Congress to get it completed.

The circumstances surrounding Gateway are fundamentally different from those surrounding ARC.

Gateway addresses infrastructure that is already critical to the national economy, including the century-old tunnels beneath the Hudson River that were damaged by Hurricane Sandy. Every day those tunnels remain the primary connection between the Northeast Corridor and Manhattan, they represent both an engineering challenge and an economic vulnerability.

The Department's role is not to dictate to the states. It's to be an honest broker, ensure federal funds are spent responsibly, keep projects moving, and resolve disputes before they become years of delay.

This is probably the most difficult question Ive been asked, because it requires me to acknowledge something every executive eventually learns.

You don't just hire people for their intelligence or experience, you hire them for their character.

Bridgegate, the conduct involving David Samson and other controversies are all episodes forced me to reevaluate how I judged people.

David Samson had decades of legal experience and was widely respected professionally. That didn't excuse what later occurred, and it certainly doesn't erase my responsibility for appointing him. Bill Baroni was someone I believed possessed tremendous ability. Bridget Kelly was a talented political operative, bowever talent is not enough. The lesson I learned is that competence without integrity is a liability.

If confirmed, my hiring philosophy would reflect that lesson. I would seek experienced people, certainly—but just as importantly, people with reputations for ethical judgment, respect for the law, and an understanding that public office is a public trust.

Every Secretary inherits thousands of career civil servants who already perform extraordinary work every day. For political appointments, my expectation would be simple: if your first instinct is to use public office for personal or political advantage, you won't work for me.

Senator, I've heard these criticisms before.

The office of Governor does not stop functioning because the Governor crosses a state line. We have lieutenant governors, emergency management professionals, cabinet officials, and communications systems precisely because government has to function continuously.

With that being said I can fully admit the "mop" comment was a mistake.

It reflected frustration with the question, not indifference toward the people affected by that storm. But that's not how it was heard, and I understand why; Words matter.

As Secretary of Transportation, I won't be running for another office. My job would be singular: serve the President, serve the American people, and ensure one of the largest transportation systems in the world operates safely and efficiently. The Department requires active leadership. It requires engagement with governors, mayors, Congress, industry, labor, and career professionals. That's exactly what I intend to provide.

NJ Transit taught me one of the hardest lessons in transportation policy; Transportation systems don't fail overnight.

They deteriorate gradually through deferred maintenance, aging equipment, workforce challenges, inconsistent investment, and management decisions that compound over time. James Weinstein inherited real structural problems, and under his tenure there were also decisions that, in hindsight, should have been handled differently. I appointed him, so ultimately that responsibility comes back to me.

What I learned is that transportation agencies cannot simply measure success by balancing budgets or completing capital projects. You have to measure success by reliability. Does the train arrive? Does the signal system work? Can commuters trust the schedule? Those are the metrics that matter to the people riding every day.

If confirmed as Secretary, I'll bring that philosophy with me. Whether it's the FAA, Amtrak, transit agencies, highways, or ports, the public doesn't judge us by press releases.

They judge us by whether the system works and if it doesn't work, they don't care whose fault it is—they expect leadership to fix it.

So, Senator, while I won't claim that every appointment I made as Governor was the right one or that every decision produced the outcome I wanted, I can tell you this:

The experiences you've described made me a more skeptical executive, a more demanding manager, and, I believe, a better prepared nominee than I would have been fifteen years ago. If the Senate confirms me, those lessons won't stay in the past—they'll shape how I lead the Department of Transportation from day one.
 
I want to thank you for your candid-ish answer, Governor Christie. I have some followups.

BRIDGEGATE
I'm glad that you say you learned your lesson from the BridgeGate debacle. However, my daughter once said she learned her lesson after we caught her smoking cigarettes and she was grounded. We caught her smoking another cigarette a week later. Habits aren't easy to be broken.

When you say that anyone found manipulating transportation systems would be removed immediately, do you mean removed immediately upon an allegation, upon credible evidence or after an internal investigation is complete?

And would the department's Inspector General be notified before your political staff had the opportunity to conduct its own internal damage assessment?

ISLAND BEACH STATE PARK
I appreciate the forthright answer you gave me regarding your unfortunately photographed vacation.

You have acknowledged that the relevant issue was not whether you possessed a legal right to use the residence, but whether exercising that privilege displayed sound judgment while the public was excluded. Is it your position today that senior officials should voluntarily decline special access during a shutdown when that access is not necessary to perform their official duties?

Would you apply that standard to yourself, your family, and every political appointee at the Department?

ARC
Governor Christie, you have repeatedly emphasized that executives must make decisions based upon the information available at the time.

You stated earlier that you emphasized that executives must make decisions based upon the information available at the time. Yes. That is true. But my next question: How will you make sure that the information reaching your desk has not been selectively curated by subordinates who already know what conclusion they hope you'll reach?

And how will you ensure that the information you're telling President Reeves is what he needs to hear as opposed to what you want him to hear? After all, you were overheard at the inaugural reception telling him what he wanted to hear.

You've also distinguished between relying on the Port Authority's legal judgment versus directing the Port Authority's legal judgment.

Did you as a former Attorney General personally review the Port Authority's legal judgment? Did you ask your Attorney General's Office to independently review the Port Authority's legal judgment?
 
I want to thank you for your candid-ish answer, Governor Christie. I have some followups.

BRIDGEGATE
I'm glad that you say you learned your lesson from the BridgeGate debacle. However, my daughter once said she learned her lesson after we caught her smoking cigarettes and she was grounded. We caught her smoking another cigarette a week later. Habits aren't easy to be broken.

When you say that anyone found manipulating transportation systems would be removed immediately, do you mean removed immediately upon an allegation, upon credible evidence or after an internal investigation is complete?

And would the department's Inspector General be notified before your political staff had the opportunity to conduct its own internal damage assessment?

ISLAND BEACH STATE PARK
I appreciate the forthright answer you gave me regarding your unfortunately photographed vacation.

You have acknowledged that the relevant issue was not whether you possessed a legal right to use the residence, but whether exercising that privilege displayed sound judgment while the public was excluded. Is it your position today that senior officials should voluntarily decline special access during a shutdown when that access is not necessary to perform their official duties?

Would you apply that standard to yourself, your family, and every political appointee at the Department?

ARC
Governor Christie, you have repeatedly emphasized that executives must make decisions based upon the information available at the time.

You stated earlier that you emphasized that executives must make decisions based upon the information available at the time. Yes. That is true. But my next question: How will you make sure that the information reaching your desk has not been selectively curated by subordinates who already know what conclusion they hope you'll reach?

And how will you ensure that the information you're telling President Reeves is what he needs to hear as opposed to what you want him to hear? After all, you were overheard at the inaugural reception telling him what he wanted to hear.

You've also distinguished between relying on the Port Authority's legal judgment versus directing the Port Authority's legal judgment.

Did you as a former Attorney General personally review the Port Authority's legal judgment? Did you ask your Attorney General's Office to independently review the Port Authority's legal judgment?
Governor Chris Christie:

You make a fair point. Saying you've learned a lesson only has value if your conduct reflects it.

When I said someone would be removed immediately, I wasn't suggesting that mere allegations should end a career. That's not consistent with due process, and frankly, it's not consistent with my background as a prosecutor.

What I mean is this: if there is credible evidence that a political appointee has used transportation authority for political retaliation or personal gain, that individual would immediately be removed from any position where they could continue exercising that authority while the matter is investigated.

Protecting the integrity of the Department comes first.

As for the Inspector General—yes, without reservation. If the allegation involves potential misconduct, abuse of authority, or violations of law, I would notify the Department's Inspector General promptly. Political staff should not be conducting an internal damage-control exercise before independent oversight is engaged.

As a general principle, I believe senior officials should voluntarily decline privileges that are unavailable to the public when those privileges are not necessary to carry out official responsibilities.

There will always be exceptions involving security, continuity of government, or emergency operations. Cabinet officials sometimes require access that ordinary citizens do not, but recreational privileges are different.

If the public is being asked to sacrifice during a shutdown, public officials should think very carefully before taking advantage of benefits that serve no governmental purpose, and yes, I would apply that standard to myself.

I would expect my family to respect it as well, because their conduct reflects on me and I would expect every political appointee in the Department to understand that perception matters almost as much as legality.

Every executive faces the risk of confirmation bias. People naturally bring you information they believe supports the direction they think you want to go. The only way to guard against that is to build a culture where disagreement isn't punished.

If confirmed, I would expect major decisions to include competing analyses whenever appropriate. If one office tells me a project carries minimal financial risk, I want to know whether another office disagrees. If lawyers raise concerns, I want those concerns presented—not summarized away. I've learned over the years that the most dangerous briefing is the one where everyone agrees too quickly.

As for President Reeves, my obligation would be to give him my honest advice. Sometimes that advice will support what he already wants to do and sometimes it won't.

A Cabinet Secretary serves at the pleasure of the President, but that doesn't relieve him of the responsibility to give candid legal and policy advice. If the President asks me what I think, he's going to get what I think—not what I imagine he wants to hear.

Now, Senator, you referenced a conversation at the inaugural reception. I don't know precisely what conversation you're referring to, and I'm certainly not going to characterize private discussions from memory. But I can tell you that over the course of my career, Presidents and governors alike have benefited more from advisers willing to disagree privately than from advisers who simply nod in agreement.

You asked whether I personally reviewed the Port Authority's legal analysis; No.

Governors simply cannot personally review every legal opinion generated by independent authorities with thousands of employees and billions of dollars in annual operations. Nor did I request that the New Jersey Attorney General independently issue a formal opinion on that specific funding question before the projects proceeded.

In retrospect, given the controversy that followed, would an independent legal review have been prudent. Perhaps. That's easy to say now but at the time, I relied on the institutional processes that existed between the Port Authority, its counsel, its board, and the respective administrations.

One lesson I've taken from that experience is that where legal authority is novel, contested, or central to a major public decision, seeking an additional independent legal review can strengthen—not weaken—the decision-making process.

If confirmed, I would not view independent legal scrutiny as an obstacle. I'd view it as a safeguard—for the Department and ultimately for the public.
 
Governor Christie, America spends too much money and takes too long to build transit, rail, bridges, and highways. Everybody knows it. The question is whether we are going to fix it or keep admiring the problem like it’s a painting in a museum.
What specific reforms would you make at DOT to lower construction costs without cutting labor standards, safety rules, or environmental protections?

Do you believe public transit is a national economic priority, or do you see it mainly as a local issue for cities and states to figure out on their own?

You were closely involved in debates over major rail infrastructure in the Northeast. As Secretary, would you commit to supporting passenger rail and major regional transit projects even when they are politically inconvenient?

Transportation is one of the largest sources of emissions in the country. What role should DOT play in cutting emissions through transit, rail, port electrification, electric vehicles, and walkable infrastructure?

Do you believe highway expansion should remain the default federal transportation strategy, or should DOT prioritize repair, safety, transit, and congestion reduction before building more lanes?

Traffic deaths remain a serious national crisis. Would you support stronger federal action on pedestrian safety, vehicle size, dangerous road design, and complete streets?

Can you commit that under your leadership, DOT-funded projects will protect prevailing wages, project labor agreements where appropriate, Buy America standards, and good union jobs?

Governor, I’ll put it plainly: are you coming to DOT to build a modern transportation system, or are you coming to pour more concrete into the same old pothole and call it progress?
 
The nominee will finish answering the remaining questions, however the time for asking questions has now expired.
 
Governor Chris Christie:

Senator Yates, I appreciate the passion behind your questions, even if I suspect we may disagree on some of the answers.

You began by saying America spends too much and takes too long to build infrastructure.

On that, we're in complete agreement.

The average American doesn't care whether a project was delayed by federal permitting, state permitting, litigation, procurement rules, or bureaucratic infighting. They just know the bridge still isn't open.

If confirmed, I would focus on making government work better.

That means coordinating federal reviews instead of forcing agencies to conduct them sequentially. It means setting deadlines for permitting decisions. It means modernizing procurement, reducing unnecessary duplication in environmental reviews where the law permits, and getting projects from the drawing board to construction more quickly.

Now, you asked me to do that without weakening labor standards, safety requirements, or environmental protections. I believe we can. Efficiency and deregulation are not the same thing. Government can be both protective of the public and less bureaucratic.

I reject the idea that public transit is merely a local concern.

When Los Angeles, New York, Chicago, San Francisco, Seattle, or Washington move millions of workers every day, that's not just helping those cities. That's helping the American economy.

The federal government has a legitimate role in supporting transit systems that have national economic significance. At the same time, states and local governments also have responsibilities. Washington shouldn't pretend it can successfully manage every transit agency in America from this building. The partnership has to go both ways.


You asked whether I'd support passenger rail even when politically inconvenient. Yes, if a project demonstrates national value, has a sound financial plan, and is ready to proceed, then politics shouldn't determine whether it receives fair consideration. I supported Gateway because I believe it's a project of national importance. I'd apply that same standard across the country.

Transportation absolutely has a role to play in reducing emissions. The Department should support innovation, cleaner technologies, more efficient freight movement, modern ports, improved transit, and infrastructure that gives Americans more transportation choices. Where I may differ from you is that I don't believe the Department's mission is to dictate how Americans choose to travel.

The Department's primary mission remains safety, mobility, and economic competitiveness. Environmental progress should complement those goals—not replace them.

No, I don't believe the answer to every congestion problem is adding another lane. Sometimes the answer is repairing existing infrastructure, sometimes it's better transit, intelligent traffic management or evenactually is expanding highway capacity. Good transportation policy begins with data, not ideology.

Traffic fatalities concern me enormously. The increase we've seen in pedestrian deaths and roadway fatalities is unacceptable. I'd support investments in safer roadway design, better intersections, improved lighting, stronger engineering standards, and technologies that reduce crashes. Every proposal deserves to be evaluated on whether it actually saves lives.

Congress has spoken clearly through statutes like the Davis-Bacon Act and Buy America requirements. As Secretary, my responsibility would be to faithfully administer those laws. Project labor agreements are a more project-specific question, and I'd evaluate them consistent with applicable law and the needs of individual projects, but let me be very clear about one thing.

America's transportation system is built by skilled men and women—many of whom belong to unions, many of whom do not. I respect all or their their work. They deserve safe workplaces, fair treatment, and confidence that federal contracts are being administered honestly.

And finally, Senator, you asked whether I'm coming to DOT to build a modern transportation system or just pour more concrete into the same pothole. I'm coming to build a transportation system that actually works. That means roads that don't crumble, bridges that don't frighten people., airports that function., railroads that run on time, ports that move freight efficiently and permitting processes that don't take longer than construction itself.

If we accomplish those things, I don't particularly care whether someone labels the approach conservative, progressive, or bipartisan. The American people will simply call it results.
 
Mr. President,

Seeing as we are out of time for questions, and Governor Christie has answered all of them, I now motion for Cloture to be invoked

I yield
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top