Currently: Q1, 2017 (Ends Sunday, November 21st at 11:59 PM EST (7 days)
Join our Discord server! See Discord icon under this banner!

Hearing: Nomination of Andrew Wheeler as EPA Administrator

Grant

Member
The Senate will come to order. The Senate will now begin the hearing on the nomination of Andrew Wheeler to be Administrator of the Environmental Protection Agency. This hearing will last 48 hours. Mr. Wheeler will waive his opening statement. Questioning may begin.
 
Last edited:
Mr. Wheeler, thank you for being here today, and listening to our riff raff.

I have looked into your bio, and your career and record speak for themselves. You have an impressive record, and I appreciate the work you have done in natural resources, as someone who has also worked as a civil servant for natural resources as well.

As the Senator from Alaska, the coastal ecosystem is extremely important to the daily lives of thousands of Alaskans. Alaska fisheries accounted for more than 60% of total U.S. harvests in studies produced by the NOAA, and I have worked in both natural resources, and in my private fishing company for many years at this point.

One of the most often overlooked environmental issues that is being seemingly swept under the rug by many in Washington DC, and in the media is ocean acidification. I am sure you are aware of this, and you are aware of the damage that increased acidification in the ocean can cause.

Now as a potential EPA director, are you concerned with the rising acidification in our oceans, and the impacts that this could have on our fisheries as well? If so, what would your department do to address or study this?

Thank You
 
Harvey:

  1. Mr. Wheeler, thank you for speaking to us today and congratulations on your nomination. Nebraska farmers don't need another speech about how much Washington appreciates agriculture. They need markets for what they grow. During your prior tenure, EPA maintained the 15-billion-gallon conventional biofuel target and opened the door to year-round E15, and I give you credit for that. But fifteen billion gallons should be a floor that is actually met, not a number EPA announces and then quietly reduces through waivers. If confirmed, will you commit to setting renewable-fuel obligations at levels that increase the real amount of corn ethanol blended into our fuel supply, expand access to E15 and higher blends, and provide Nebraska growers with predictable long-term demand? What specific annual conventional-biofuel target would you recommend to the President?
  2. During your previous service at EPA, the agency granted 31 small-refinery exemptions in a single round. Corn growers saw those exemptions as gallons taken directly out of the renewable-fuels market. EPA later tried to compensate for expected exemptions when calculating annual obligations, but farmers were left wondering whether the promise of 15 billion gallons actually meant 15 billion gallons in practice or was just another broken promise from Washington. If confirmed, will you commit that every gallon waived through a small-refinery exemption will be reallocated to the remaining obligated refiners, so that hardship relief for one refinery does not become a financial penalty on Nebraska farmers? Would you support full reallocation, rather than leaving farmers to absorb the lost demand, and will you publish the evidence supporting each exemption so the public can determine whether a refinery faces genuine disproportionate hardship?
  3. Nebraska producers need effective tools to control resistant weeds, but farmers also need certainty that products used on one field will not damage a neighbor’s crops. The over-the-top dicamba registrations approved during your previous tenure were later vacated by a federal court, in significant part because EPA failed to provide the required public-notice process; not because Congress prohibited dicamba or because farmers suddenly stopped needing it. If confirmed, will you commit to conducting a lawful, transparent, science-based registration process that preserves access to dicamba and other essential crop-protection products where they can be used safely? Specifically, would you support renewed dicamba registrations with enforceable application dates, drift and volatility protections, state flexibility, applicator training, and enough lead time that Nebraska farmers are not forced to make planting and seed decisions without knowing which products will legally be available?
 
1. Administrator-designate Wheeler, President Reeves has called for expanding offshore oil and gas drilling. I represent Washington State, a state whose economy and way of life are deeply connected to the Pacific Ocean.

Can you commit today that the EPA will not weaken environmental protections or use its authority to facilitate offshore drilling in areas where the risks of an oil spill or other pollution would threaten coastal communities, fisheries, and marine ecosystems?

2. The oil companies that profit from offshore drilling do not bear the full cost of an environmental disaster. The fishermen, coastal businesses, local governments, and taxpayers often do.

What specific protections would you require to ensure that the public is not left paying for the environmental consequences of a private company's decision to drill?

3. I spent much of my career working in cybersecurity and critical infrastructure. One lesson I learned is that responsible operators do not design systems around the assumption that nothing will ever go wrong. They plan for failure.

When the consequences of an environmental accident could be catastrophic, should regulators base their decisions on the most optimistic projection of risk, or should they plan for credible worst-case scenarios?

4. Administrator-designate, Puget Sound is not just a scenic body of water. It is an economic resource, an ecological system, and a source of cultural and economic importance to Tribal nations and communities throughout Washington State.

The decline of salmon populations is tied in part to water quality, toxic chemicals, stormwater runoff, and habitat degradation. Will you commit to treating the restoration of Puget Sound as a national environmental priority and to working with Washington State, Tribal governments, and local communities to meet the federal government's obligations to protect it?

5. The health of salmon populations is directly connected to the treaty rights and cultural survival of Tribal nations in the Pacific Northwest.

When environmental degradation threatens both an ecosystem and treaty-protected rights, does the EPA have a responsibility to give those impacts special consideration in its decisions?
 
Mr. Wheeler, thank you for being here today, and listening to our riff raff.

I have looked into your bio, and your career and record speak for themselves. You have an impressive record, and I appreciate the work you have done in natural resources, as someone who has also worked as a civil servant for natural resources as well.

As the Senator from Alaska, the coastal ecosystem is extremely important to the daily lives of thousands of Alaskans. Alaska fisheries accounted for more than 60% of total U.S. harvests in studies produced by the NOAA, and I have worked in both natural resources, and in my private fishing company for many years at this point.

One of the most often overlooked environmental issues that is being seemingly swept under the rug by many in Washington DC, and in the media is ocean acidification. I am sure you are aware of this, and you are aware of the damage that increased acidification in the ocean can cause.

Now as a potential EPA director, are you concerned with the rising acidification in our oceans, and the impacts that this could have on our fisheries as well? If so, what would your department do to address or study this?

Thank You
Andrew Wheeler:

Thank you, Senator Douglas. And thank you for your kind remarks. I appreciate your background in both public service and the fishing industry. I think that gives you a practical perspective on these issues that is extremely valuable.

You're absolutely right that Alaska's fisheries are not just an environmental resource—they're an economic engine, a cultural institution, and a source of food security for communities across your state and the nation. The health of those fisheries is something that deserves serious attention.

With respect to ocean acidification, yes, I do consider it a legitimate environmental concern. It is an issue that has been studied for years by NOAA, EPA, and the scientific community because of its potential impacts on shellfish, coral ecosystems, and certain commercially important fish species. While there remain areas where additional research is warranted—particularly regarding regional differences and long-term ecosystem responses—I don't believe it's appropriate to dismiss the issue or pretend it doesn't exist.

If confirmed, EPA's role would be to continue providing sound scientific analysis within the authority Congress has given the Agency. Ocean acidification is a complex issue influenced by multiple factors, including global carbon dioxide concentrations, local water chemistry, nutrient runoff, and other regional environmental conditions. That means it is not a challenge any single agency—or frankly, any single nation—can solve by itself.

From EPA's standpoint, I would focus on three areas.

First, I would ensure that EPA continues to support high-quality scientific research and monitoring in coordination with NOAA, the U.S. Geological Survey, state environmental agencies, tribal governments, and academic institutions. Good policy starts with good science, and Alaska provides some of the most important opportunities in the world to study these changes.

Second, I would look for opportunities within EPA's existing statutory authorities to improve local water quality. While reducing nutrient pollution and improving watershed management won't solve global ocean acidification, they can reduce additional stressors on coastal ecosystems and make them more resilient.

Third, I think it's important that EPA maintain a close partnership with states like Alaska. You understand your fisheries, your coastal communities, and your ecosystems better than anyone in Washington. I have long believed environmental protection works best when the federal government serves as a partner with the states rather than assuming it has all the answers.

I also want to be clear about something, Senator. Protecting our fisheries and supporting responsible economic activity are not mutually exclusive goals. Healthy fisheries support jobs, commercial harvests, recreational opportunities, tourism, and entire coastal economies. Those outcomes benefit everyone, regardless of political affiliation.

So yes, I take ocean acidification seriously. I believe EPA has a responsibility to contribute rigorous science, collaborate closely with our federal and state partners, and ensure that decisions are grounded in the best available evidence while remaining within the authority Congress has entrusted to the Agency.
 
1. Administrator-designate Wheeler, President Reeves has called for expanding offshore oil and gas drilling. I represent Washington State, a state whose economy and way of life are deeply connected to the Pacific Ocean.

Can you commit today that the EPA will not weaken environmental protections or use its authority to facilitate offshore drilling in areas where the risks of an oil spill or other pollution would threaten coastal communities, fisheries, and marine ecosystems?

2. The oil companies that profit from offshore drilling do not bear the full cost of an environmental disaster. The fishermen, coastal businesses, local governments, and taxpayers often do.

What specific protections would you require to ensure that the public is not left paying for the environmental consequences of a private company's decision to drill?

3. I spent much of my career working in cybersecurity and critical infrastructure. One lesson I learned is that responsible operators do not design systems around the assumption that nothing will ever go wrong. They plan for failure.

When the consequences of an environmental accident could be catastrophic, should regulators base their decisions on the most optimistic projection of risk, or should they plan for credible worst-case scenarios?

4. Administrator-designate, Puget Sound is not just a scenic body of water. It is an economic resource, an ecological system, and a source of cultural and economic importance to Tribal nations and communities throughout Washington State.

The decline of salmon populations is tied in part to water quality, toxic chemicals, stormwater runoff, and habitat degradation. Will you commit to treating the restoration of Puget Sound as a national environmental priority and to working with Washington State, Tribal governments, and local communities to meet the federal government's obligations to protect it?

5. The health of salmon populations is directly connected to the treaty rights and cultural survival of Tribal nations in the Pacific Northwest.

When environmental degradation threatens both an ecosystem and treaty-protected rights, does the EPA have a responsibility to give those impacts special consideration in its decisions?
Andrew Wheeler:

On your first question regarding offshore energy development, it is important to recognize that EPA is not the agency that decides whether offshore lease areas are opened. Those decisions primarily fall to the Department of the Interior under the Outer Continental Shelf Lands Act.

EPA's responsibility is different. Our responsibility is to faithfully implement the environmental laws Congress has enacted, including the Clean Water Act, the Clean Air Act, and other applicable statutes. If confirmed, I will not instruct the Agency to ignore statutory requirements or weaken environmental protections simply to facilitate development. Every project that comes before EPA should be evaluated under the law and on the facts specific to that project.

That also means I don't believe in creating unnecessary barriers where projects can meet the environmental standards Congress has established. Environmental protection and domestic energy production are not mutually exclusive if projects are conducted responsibly and in compliance with the law.

Regarding your second question, I agree with the premise that companies operating offshore should bear responsibility for the environmental consequences of their activities.

A company seeking to operate offshore should demonstrate that it has robust spill prevention measures, emergency response capabilities, financial resources to address potential damages, and compliance with all applicable environmental requirements. The "polluter pays" principle is an important component of our environmental laws. Taxpayers should not be expected to shoulder costs that properly belong to the responsible party.

EPA's role is to ensure that applicable environmental standards are enforced consistently and that operators are held accountable when violations occur.

On your third question concerning risk assessment, I think your cybersecurity analogy is actually an appropriate one.

No responsible regulator—or operator—should assume that accidents are impossible. Planning for credible worst-case scenarios is a fundamental component of responsible environmental regulation.

At the same time, regulatory decisions should be based on the best available science, engineering analysis, and evidence. We shouldn't rely on either unrealistically optimistic assumptions or speculative hypotheticals that have little basis in the facts. Good regulation evaluates credible risks, prepares for them, and requires operators to demonstrate that they can prevent, mitigate, and respond effectively if something does go wrong.

With respect to Puget Sound, I recognize its extraordinary environmental, economic, and cultural importance—not only to Washington State but to the nation.

EPA has been a longstanding partner in Puget Sound restoration, and if confirmed I intend to continue that partnership. Restoration efforts involving water quality improvements, contaminated sediment cleanup, habitat restoration, and stormwater management have produced measurable benefits over many years, and I believe those collaborative efforts should continue.

I also believe these efforts are strongest when they involve federal agencies, state and local governments, Tribal governments, scientists, and the communities directly affected.

Finally, on Tribal treaty rights.

EPA has a longstanding trust responsibility to engage with Tribal governments, and I fully intend to honor that responsibility if confirmed.

While EPA itself does not determine the scope of treaty rights—that is ultimately a matter of law and, where necessary, the courts—our decisions should absolutely take into account the impacts that environmental degradation may have on Tribal communities and on resources that are protected under federal law.

Meaningful Tribal consultation should not be treated as a procedural box to check. It should be an opportunity to understand how EPA actions affect communities with unique legal rights, historical relationships to the land and water, and generations of environmental knowledge.
 
Mr. Wheeler, the job title is Environmental Protection Administrator. Not industry protection administrator. Not pollution permission administrator. Environmental Protection Administrator.
Do you believe EPA’s first duty is to protect public health and the environment, even when that makes fossil fuel companies, chemical companies, or major polluters unhappy?

Do you accept that climate change is real, primarily driven by human activity, and already harming American communities?

During your prior time at EPA, critics argued that the agency weakened environmental protections and favored industry. Why should communities facing dirty air, poisoned water, and industrial pollution trust you now?

Low-income communities, Black communities, Latino communities, Indigenous communities, and working-class industrial towns are often hit first and worst by pollution. What specific enforcement tools would you use to protect environmental justice communities?

Would you commit to aggressive enforcement of clean water protections, including against industrial polluters, agricultural runoff, and companies contaminating drinking water?

Should EPA be helping the United States transition away from fossil fuel dependence, or do you believe the agency should simply manage pollution after the damage is already done?

Will you commit to increasing inspections, civil penalties, and enforcement actions against repeat polluters, even when those polluters are politically powerful?

Mr. Wheeler, putting polluters on the honor system makes about as much sense as giving a raccoon the keys to the pantry. Why should this committee believe you will be a watchdog for the public instead of a welcome mat for industry?
 
The nominee will finish answering the remaining questions, however the time for asking questions has now expired.
 
((OOC: Apologies for the delay))

Andrew Wheeler to Henry Yates:

Senator, I appreciate the questions, and I think several of them touch on issues that have already come up during today's hearing, so where appropriate I will refer back to those answers rather than unnecessarily repeat myself.

On your first question, yes. EPA's fundamental mission is protecting human health and the environment under the laws Congress has enacted. As I said earlier in response to Senator Lee, I will not instruct EPA to ignore or weaken statutory environmental requirements simply because compliance may be inconvenient for a particular industry. At the same time, I do not believe protecting the environment requires EPA to be hostile toward lawful economic activity. Our obligation is to enforce the law fairly, consistently, and based upon the facts.

On climate change, I accept that the climate is changing and that human activity contributes significantly to that change. There are legitimate policy debates about the proper regulatory response, the costs and benefits of individual regulations, and the authority Congress has provided EPA. But I do not believe there is a legitimate basis for EPA to simply disregard the scientific evidence.

As to why communities should trust me, Senator, I recognize that my previous tenure will be examined closely. I am not asking anyone to ignore that record. What I can commit to is that decisions under my leadership will be made under the statutes Congress enacted, the administrative record before the Agency, and the best available science. Where a company violates environmental law, I do not believe its political influence, size, or industry should shield it from enforcement.

On communities that have historically borne disproportionate pollution burdens, EPA has a number of existing tools available, including inspections, permitting oversight, civil enforcement, emergency authorities where applicable, environmental monitoring, and coordination with state, local, and Tribal governments. As I noted earlier when discussing Tribal communities and Puget Sound, consultation should be meaningful rather than simply a box EPA checks after a decision has already been made.

On clean water enforcement, yes, I will enforce the Clean Water Act. That applies to industrial facilities and other regulated sources within EPA's statutory jurisdiction. Where Congress has divided responsibility among EPA, the states, and other agencies, I will respect those boundaries, but regulated entities do not get a pass simply because enforcement may be politically difficult.

With respect to transitioning away from fossil fuels, I do not believe Congress created EPA to centrally plan the nation's energy economy. EPA's job is to regulate pollution under environmental statutes. Energy markets, technological innovation, legislation passed by Congress, and decisions made by consumers and businesses will all influence the country's long-term energy mix. EPA should ensure that whatever sources of energy Americans use comply with the environmental protections established by law.

You also asked about inspections and enforcement against repeat violators. Yes. Repeat violations should be taken seriously. I would expect EPA's enforcement personnel to consider a company's compliance history when determining the appropriate response. As I said earlier regarding offshore drilling, taxpayers should not be left responsible for environmental damage properly attributable to a private operator, and politically powerful companies should be subject to the same laws as everyone else.

Finally, Senator, I appreciate the raccoon analogy.

I don't believe environmental protection works by putting polluters on the honor system. Effective environmental regulation requires clear rules, credible monitoring, inspections where appropriate, accurate reporting, and consequences when the law is violated.

But being a watchdog does not mean assuming everyone EPA regulates is guilty before examining the facts. My responsibility, if confirmed, will be neither to serve industry nor to wage war against it. It will be to administer the Environmental Protection Agency faithfully, enforce the laws Congress has enacted, protect public health and the environment, and make decisions that can withstand scientific, legal, and public scrutiny.

I believe that is the standard this Senate should hold me to, Senator.
 
Back
Top