Currently: Q1, 2017 (Ends Sunday, November 21st at 11:59 PM EST (7 days)
Join our Discord server! See Discord icon under this banner!

New Florida immigration law faces federal court challenge

Brink

Member
Player Media
kansaswx_Editorial_conceptual_image_showing_the_Florida_state_44e6fd76-5034-4bef-a49a-636cc301...png
New Florida immigration law faces federal court challenge
Judicial | Q1, 2026​

TALLAHASSEE, FLORIDA — The Florida Immigrant Coalition filed suit against Attorney General James Uthmeier on Thursday, asking the Eleventh Circuit to block a new state law that creates Florida criminal penalties for immigrants who entered the United States illegally or returned after previously being removed.

The lawsuit, Florida Immigrant Coalition v. Uthmeier, argues that Florida has crossed the constitutional line between assisting federal immigration enforcement and creating its own immigration system.

Under the Illegal Entry/Reentry Act, which passed the state legislature last year, an unauthorized immigrant who enters Florida after avoiding federal immigration inspection can face a mandatory nine-month prison sentence.

The law separately makes it a felony for certain immigrants who were previously deported or removed to later enter or be found in Florida, with mandatory sentences that can increase based on prior convictions.

The statute also directs courts to presume that defendants charged under either provision should remain detained while their cases are pending.

The coalition contends those provisions are preempted by federal immigration law.

“A State may not create its own parallel immigration enforcement system simply because it seeks additional or more severe penalties than Congress has provided,” the filing reads.

The plaintiffs rely heavily on the Supreme Court's 2012 decision in Arizona v. United States, which limited states' ability to create their own immigration offenses where Congress has already established a comprehensive federal enforcement framework.

The suit also challenges the law's mandatory detention provisions under the Due Process Clause, arguing that courts must retain the ability to consider an individual defendant's flight risk and danger to the community rather than beginning with a statutory presumption against release.

The coalition is asking the Eleventh Circuit to declare the entry and reentry provisions unconstitutional and prevent Uthmeier and other Florida officials from enforcing them.

The filing sets up what could become one of the most consequential tests yet of Florida's increasingly aggressive role in immigration enforcement and a direct examination of how far states may go when federal and state officials share the same goal but rely on different legal authority.
 
Back
Top