WASHINGTON, D.C. — Representative Eric Swalwell (D-California) is refusing to resign despite mounting bipartisan pressure following allegations of sexual misconduct from four women, as lawmakers begin weighing what formal action the House could take against him.
The most damaging break for Swalwell came from within his own party, with Speaker of the House Marco Reyes (D-Michigan) publicly calling for his resignation.
“Four women have come forward. This isn’t about politics, it’s about whether Congress means what it says when it tells survivors to come forward,” Reyes said. “Rep. Swalwell should resign.”
But what might have become a rapid Democratic stampede away from Swalwell was complicated by an extraordinary intervention from Senator Howie Schmidt (D-Montana).
“Back on the farm, we used to do this thing called gelding when a steer was too aggressive or violent towards the females,” Schmidt told CNN. “Frankly, if the reports are true, I'd be more than happy to teach the Sergeant of Arms how to work the clamps and a Newberry Knife on Congressman Swalwell.”
The comment immediately generated a controversy of its own, with lawmakers confronting questions about a Democratic senator appearing to advocate the physical mutilation of an accused colleague before the allegations against him had been adjudicated.
For some Democrats, Schmidt’s intervention became a tipping point toward caution.
Rather than immediately following Reyes in demanding Swalwell’s resignation, lawmakers began stressing that the House should proceed deliberately before imposing punishment, while separately condemning Schmidt’s rhetoric.
Schmidt’s remarks drew widespread condemnation in Washington, D.C. but they also found an unlikely cheering section on some corners of the right, where some commentators treated the Montana senator’s language as crude but refreshingly direct.
On Newsmax, conservative personalities joked about Schmidt’s ranch imagery while acknowledging that suggesting the physical mutilation of a member of Congress was far outside normal political discourse.
Mike Lindell went further, praising Schmidt for saying what he believed ordinary Americans were thinking while giving the Democratic senator an unusual cross party stamp of approval.
“I like this guy Schmidt,” Lindell said. “Was it polite? No. Was it Washington-approved? Definitely not. That’s probably why people liked it. He’s rough around the edges, but at least he tells you exactly what he thinks. He’s got my stamp of approval.”
The unusual reaction highlighted the complicated political terrain surrounding Schmidt’s comments: shocking to much of Washington, but potentially appealing to a slice of voters who interpreted the outburst less as a literal threat than as an expression of disgust with alleged misconduct by powerful politicians.
However, those same comments gave Swalwell an opening:
The embattled congressman condemned Schmidt’s remarks while maintaining his denial of the accusations against him, arguing that violent rhetoric had no place in the debate over his future.
“These allegations are serious, and I have said I will cooperate with any legitimate investigation,” Swalwell said. “But suggesting that I should be physically mutilated is grotesque, dangerous and beneath the dignity of the United States Senate. I categorically deny these allegations, and I will defend myself through facts and due process, not threats of political violence. Senator Schmidt should retract those comments and apologize.”
Swalwell also called on fellow Democrats to condemn Schmidt’s comments.
“If a Republican senator had suggested castrating a Democratic member of Congress, Democrats would rightly condemn it as violent rhetoric,” Swalwell said. “We cannot have one standard when the target is politically convenient.”
That hesitation has left Swalwell with just enough political space to remain in office for now, even as his standing within the Democratic caucus has deteriorated dramatically.
Republicans continued to increase the pressure.
House Minority Leader Louie MacArthur (R-Georgia) stopped short of declaring Swalwell guilty but said his future in Congress should be clear if the accusations are substantiated.
“If the allegations are true, Eric Swalwell has no business being in the House!” MacArthur posted on X.
Senator Daniel Titus (R-Florida) went considerably further, dispensing with MacArthur’s conditional language and demanding Swalwell leave Congress immediately.
“Rep. Swalwell needs to resign,” Titus said. “The limp dick doesn’t understand the word no and should leave office.”
The crude attack added another resignation demand to the pressure surrounding Swalwell, but it also gave the California Democrat another example of what his allies characterized as opponents turning serious allegations into a partisan spectacle.
People close to Swalwell said remarks like Titus’s coupled with Schmidt’s earlier comments about “gelding” him were more likely to harden Swalwell’s determination to remain in office than persuade him to resign.
White House Press Secretary Augustus King similarly said on X that “if the allegations of Swalwell is true he needs to be voted out and censured.”
Attention is now beginning to turn toward what the House itself might do if Swalwell refuses to leave voluntarily.
Members could introduce resolutions ranging from condemnation or censure to more severe disciplinary measures. Expulsion, the most drastic option available to the chamber and one requiring a two-thirds vote, could also begin to enter conversations surrounding Swalwell’s future, although there is not yet evidence that such a supermajority exists.
The competing developments have left Swalwell in an unusual position: the Speaker believes he should resign, Republicans are demanding consequences if the allegations are substantiated, and lawmakers are openly discussing formal House action against him.
Yet Schmidt’s incendiary comments may have prevented the first day from becoming a complete political collapse by giving wavering Democrats a reason to resist an immediate rush toward punishment without requiring them to defend Swalwell himself.
With four women accusing him of misconduct, Swalwell remains deeply endangered.
But for now, he is staying while believing he retains just enough political support to resist calls for his immediate departure.
